Doctor Torres

Dr. Ernesto Torres’ office on Thomas Johnson Drive in Frederick.

Patients of Dr. Ernesto Torres were left scrambling for a new doctor after police arrested the Frederick pediatrician in May on sexual assault charges involving at least 12 patients.

For a subset of Torres’ patients, leaving his practice meant losing a doctor familiar with their culture and their native language, Spanish.

Frederick police arrested Torres first on May 7 after a grand jury indicted him on charges of rape and sexual assault involving a single patient. He posted bail, but was arrested again nearly two weeks later after he was indicted on 65 more counts involving 11 other patients.

Detectives are investigating additional cases, said Frederick County State’s Attorney’s Office spokesman Will Cockey.

At an initial bail review hearing, Torres, 68, voiced concerns about his patients, especially those who primarily speak Spanish, if he could not practice. Approximately two weeks later, a Frederick County Circuit Court judge ordered Torres to cease practicing while criminal charges were pending, leaving his patients looking for a new doctor — at least temporarily.

Torres’ attorney Richard Bricken said the doctor is more concerned about his patients than he is himself. Bricken spoke to The News-Post before the additional charges were filed against Torres.

“There’s been a tremendous amount of support for Dr. Torres coming from his patients,” Bricken said.

Pediatric and family medicine doctors around the county are accepting new patients, but not all of them provide a Spanish-speaking doctor.

Torres is a well-known pediatrician in the Latino community, said Dr. Julio Menocal, a family medicine physician in Frederick who is fluent in Spanish. Menocal, who accepts all Medicaid plans, said he is accepting patients.

“A lot of doctors in town are bilingual, but primary care, I’m not so sure there are that many,” Menocal said.

Calling around to pediatrician offices in the county reveals that while some practices do have at least one Spanish-speaking doctor, many rely on language lines and interpreters to see patients who might speak Spanish.

Spanish-speaking doctors

Menocal is one of the first doctors to come to mind when seeking a Spanish-speaking doctor. Menocal’s practice has 12 Spanish-speaking members on the staff of 20, and he serves many children of immigrants, he said. He recently hired a nurse practitioner who speaks Spanish.

Even if a patient speaks Spanish, it does not necessarily mean that the doctor they see will speak the same dialect. While Spanish is the common language, each country has its own slang or take on the language, just as American English differs from British English.

“The most important thing to realize is even though these are Hispanics, every country has a different set of slang and idioms that are unique to their cultures,” Menocal said. “And I think having the flexibility to understand what they mean by certain expressions is probably what Dr. Torres was striving at in stating that it’s better to have a Spanish-speaking [physician].”

Whether a patient seeks out a Spanish-speaking doctor is a personal choice, and where someone goes for medical services might depend on their insurance coverage. Even among medical professionals, there is no consensus on whether a patient who speaks primarily Spanish should seek out a doctor who speaks Spanish.

Ellyse Lopez Lamont, a nurse practitioner with Monocacy Health Partners Immediate Care, is bilingual. She was born in Puerto Rico.

When she speaks Spanish to a patient, she says the guard comes down. The patient is more comfortable and willing to speak with her. Medicine is personal, and being able to understand without going through interpretation can help foster a better relationship with the patient, especially in immediate care where the patient is coming in for a one-time visit.

“When a patient speaks to you directly, and there’s no in-between person, you get exactly what they are saying,” Lopez Lamont said. “I understand in their gestures, in the way they talk. I understand their mannerisms as I’m speaking to them.”

That’s not to say translation services are not effective, she said, but words can get lost in translation, especially if medical jargon is used. For example, a translator might translate the word cervical when a doctor is talking about the neck area, which might be too technical for some patients, she said.

But not all medical professionals agree. Dr. Jose Muniz, an immunologist and allergist in the county, said there is little difference between seeing a doctor fluent in Spanish and using an interpreter trained in medical language.

“If you have a medical interpreter — English, Spanish — oh, yes, they will be phenomenal for anybody because they are trained to do that very quickly,” Muniz said.

Culture

Having a doctor who speaks a patient’s primary language is not always important, but a doctor who understands the culture is, Menocal said.

Many of his patients on the Golden Mile do not have extended family to help with issues the children might have. So his practice becomes a de facto family, something Menocal encourages.

He asks that his patients and patients’ parents develop relationships with medical assistants and office staff so they feel comfortable asking questions. Patients and their families turn to his practice for information about vaccinations or dieting.

“They kind of rely on us for a lot of things, kind of to guide them through the system,” he said.

But like the Spanish language, the Latino community is an umbrella term. Each country has its own culture, Muniz said.

“It’s like English. Not all English-speaking countries have the same culture,” he said. “The people in New Zealand have [a] different [culture] than the one in Scotland. Here [it] is the same. The people in Buenos Aires, Argentina, have one culture, and the people in El Salvador have another culture. They have in common the language, and stop right there — nothing else in common.”

Lopez Lamont agreed. She speaks with the mannerisms and dialect of someone who is from Puerto Rico, which are similar to those of Cuba. And people from those areas light up when she treats them because they connect through language and culture.

But that applies only to those from Puerto Rico and, sometimes, Cuba.

Doctors accepting patients

Torres’ office and Torres’ head attorney declined to comment about where the office is referring patients. Torres posted bail and is on house arrest while awaiting trial.

Menocal’s practice on the Golden Mile accepts all medical assistance HMO plans, known as HMCO, whereas other offices might accept only one or two, he said.

His practice is also the only one in town to see babies before they get insured, he said.

Dr. James Lee, a pediatrician in New Market, is also accepting new patients, but the doctor does not speak Spanish, a receptionist said.

One practice patients of Torres might visit is Dr. Steven Alcuri. The Frederick doctor is a single pediatrician office like Torres’, practice manager Kim Mazziott said. Alcuri usually filled in for Torres when he was sick or on vacation.

Alcuri’s office is working with the office manager and staff at Torres’ office to get records of patients so that the transfer is as seamless as possible, Mazziott said.

“Just taking care of their needs, that’s our main priority, is to serve the community and the families, because this has been an extremely difficult ordeal for them,” she said. “And we’re just trying to make it as uncomplicated and simple as we can to keep them going.”

Mazziott blocked off time for Alcuri to see patients from Torres’ office. And they are trying to get Torres’ patients into appointments as quickly as they can, even striving to schedule well-visits on the same day they were scheduled with Torres.

Alcuri and his staff do not speak Spanish, but the practice uses interpreter services, most of which are approved by insurance, she said.

Follow Heather Mongilio on Twitter:

@HMongilio.

Heather Mongilio is the health and Fort Detrick reporter for the Frederick News-Post. She can be reached at hmongilio@newspost.com.

(18) comments

niceund

He didn't care about them when he was assaulting them. I feel for those who are having language barrier issues right now. It might be a good time to learn English.

Comment deleted.
mgoose806

They can always go home to their 3rd world country or better yet, move to Montgomery County.

mgoose806

Stupid article implying that this potential felon has any value being in Frederick at all. It didn't matter he spoke Spanish for the first 25 years he was in this County. No let's us the Spanish Speaking Doctor is something to consider in his future.

Comment deleted.
FCPS-Principal

Spare us the nonsense about how good health care and law enforcement here is.

Comment deleted.
gabrielshorn2013

Huh? Does the good doctor not speak English? Are you attributing all of these faults to Dr. Torres? Furthermore, COMMUNICATION is one of the most important aspects of treating patients. You can't treat them if they cannot tell you what hurts.

Comment deleted.
KellyAlzan

I feel bad for you.

KellyAlzan

For this many people to come forewarn, I feel he isn’t so innocent. However, to convict, the state needs at least one of the following: a) evidence b) witness or witnesses c) an admittance of guilt Because the majority of allegations took place over a decade ago, and because the state lacks of the 3 Aforementioned necessities to convinct, the state has a nearly impossible task of proving he is guilty.

KellyAlzan

Should say “because the state lacks any of the 3 aforementioned.....”

sevenstones1000

The former patients are already testifying. You do not need an outside “witness” to sexual assault.

KellyAlzan

“Testifying”. Big wow. Par for the course.

mr_twist27

I guess you know everything about this case?

KellyAlzan

Didn’t say that. But I do know a little about proving guilt.

firedupterp

Kelly = judge and jury

KellyAlzan

I believe we all learned about evidence and witnesses with the judge Kavinahh case . That. And, why did the FCSO deputy not get convicted on his initial charges?

firedupterp

yes, that it was a smear campaign

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Engage ideas. This forum is for the exchange of ideas, insights and experiences, not personal attacks. Ad hominen criticisms are not allowed. Focus on ideas instead.
TURN OFF CAPS LOCK.
Don't threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
No trolls. Off-topic comments and comments that bait others are not allowed.
No spamming. This is not the place to sell miracle cures.
Say it once. No repeat or repetitive posts, please.
Help us. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.