The baby shoes sit on the mantel, the fibers of the laces peeking through the bronze coating.
Terry Horman looks at them each day. Sometimes it’s a quick glance. Other times, a longer gaze. Such is the life of the mother of a murder victim whose death is long unsolved.
After the detectives leave and reporters stop calling, after the funeral is over and friends and neighbors have expressed all the condolences they have to give, there’s an attempt to return to life.
But the experience of losing a loved one in unexplained circumstances isn’t one that’s easy to shake. For the families and detectives tied to Frederick County’s unsolved murders, peace and peace of mind are forever elusive.
The Frederick Police Department lists 11 open homicide cases on their website. The Frederick County Sheriff's Office lists three.
Joshua Crawford
Joshua Crawford liked to draw and paint. He liked to fish and would make his own flies. He was a mama’s boy. He called Horman each day and came over for meals.
He especially liked chocolate cake and chocolate ice cream — the birthday dessert Horman planned to make for him when she received the call that Crawford had been found dead.
He was found beaten and bound with duct tape in his Kingsbrook apartment. It was June 2, 2003 — his 21st birthday.
Horman doesn’t remember much from the days following Crawford’s death. She was so distraught, her doctor placed her on medication.
One of the few things she has to remember the day of Crawford’s funeral and burial is a photograph. In it, she stands in the green grass of Clustered Spires Cemetery, wrapped in her mother’s arms, her face turned toward a mound of earth and flowers.
“I don’t even remember this picture being taken,” she said.
She gained weight. She couldn’t pay her bills. Not because she didn’t have the money, but because she couldn’t bring herself to sit down and write out the checks.
“Our credit got really bad,” she said. “I told companies they needed to call me and get on me about it because otherwise they weren’t going to get paid.”
The nights were the hardest, she said. When the daycare she runs out of her home closed and the children left, the quiet of the house was painful. There was no distraction to keep her occupied.
In the wood-paneled dining room of her Frederick home, she maintains a shrine for Crawford. His baby shoes are there, along with a drawing he did of the view from his apartment window and an old Mother’s Day card. A photo of him in his orange, white and blue Little League uniform. Another in the bathtub, a smiling little boy surrounded by soapy water.
“I know he did drugs,” she said. “I know he wasn’t perfect, but he was a good kid.”
Her other sons found different means to grieve. One turned to alcohol and the other had an emotional breakdown five years after Crawford’s death. They try to work together as a family. At dinners and holidays like Christmas and Thanksgiving, they like to share their favorite memories of Joshua.
Assigned duty
Body counts are inherently misleading, said Lt. Clark Pennington, commander of the criminal investigations division of the Frederick Police Department. There are always victims you don’t bury, that walk around deadened by the loss and burdened by uncertainty.
Every detective is assigned at least one long-term case in addition to their regular caseload in the criminal investigations unit, Pennington said, and the officers work to maintain a support system.
They watch each other to ensure that a particular case doesn’t begin to wear down an officer.
They find it helps to rotate the cases among officers, Pennington said, both for the emotional health of the detectives and the case’s progression.
They also make sure to reach out to the victim’s family several times a year to provide updates.
“This victim, and we hate to call them victims, has a family that deserves closure,” Pennington said. “That’s what motivates these guys. They’re looking to close them.”
Tracey Lynn Kirkpatrick
Deonda Kirkpatrick brought a bouquet of yellow daffodils; a color that would complement the plum leaves of her sister Tracey’s memorial tree outside Brunswick High School.
In 1989, Tracey Lynn Kirkpatrick, 17, was found stabbed to death in the back room of the Frederick ladies’ clothing store where she worked. No motive has been discovered. No arrests were ever made.
Deonda said she's a talker. Her personal form of therapy is talking about it to those she meets, and it serves a dual purpose: she can search for leads, evaluate acquaintances as possible suspects. She’s been doing it so long, it’s become a habit.
She was 19 when they found Tracey’s body. Jack, Tracey’s brother, was 21. Angie, the youngest, was 16.
The family had been living in Point of Rocks for only about 2 1/2 years. It was a shock to the community and the family — she was a nice girl, they said.
Tracey liked to write poetry. She was quiet and thoughtful. She cared about her schoolwork and her two jobs and was saving money for college. Yet, her murder was so violent and sudden.
Diane and Billy Kirkpatrick, Tracey’s parents, kept their surviving children on a tight leash afterward. Deonda and Jack moved back home. They called each other constantly to check in and if they weren’t home when Billy estimated they should be, he went looking for them.
And when Deonda Kirkpatrick had her two children, she never felt comfortable with them out of sight.
“I don’t know if this guy who did it, does he have a vendetta against my family?” Deonda Kirkpatrick said. “Is he going to come for one of us next? Is he going to take my kids?”
The family gets recognized on the street and they answer questions, but it’s still hard after all this time.
“It comes up at dinner and you talk about it for a little bit,” Billy Kirkpatrick said. "But then you don’t want to talk about it anymore.”
The Kirkpatricks live with constant tension. The Frederick police, who are handling the case, have kept their word and update the family as they can, but knowing of a development and not having it pan out is almost as bad as not knowing at all.
“They usually call around the anniversary. They build you up and then nothing happens,” Billy said. “Sometimes, it seems like stuff just to get me off their mind.”
The long wait
As the years go on, there’s a shift. Where once the hardest part of living was knowing that Joshua or Tracey were never coming back, feelings of not being heard become the greatest struggle.
Horman said she feels angry and frustrated that the investigation seems to be going nowhere. She’s actively investigating herself, finding suspects and tracking down their contact information.
She feels as though her son’s case doesn’t matter to the sheriff's office, even if investigators are still working on it. On a few occasions, she’s been close to getting arrested for hindering the investigation.
“These are open doors for me. I can’t just sit here,” Horman said. “What does the community care about victims of crimes?”
Still, Horman said she would go to jail for her investigating if it came to it.
“It’s sad that it’s 10 years later,” she said. “Ten years. It’s like biting a bullet.”
The Kirkpatricks have taken a less aggressive approach. Both Jack and Deonda were turned down for jobs at the city police department, and have considered hiring a private investigator.
“You have to believe that they’re doing it,” Billy said.
The cases are still open. The families live life each day with the knowledge that they don’t know what happened, and the fear they may never find answers is constant.
“There's a fear of dying," Jack said. "Once we’re all gone, there’s no one to push the investigation and remember."
Follow Laura Blasey on Twitter: @lblasey.
BY THE NUMBERS
In 2010, Maryland ranked 2nd nationally for highest murder rate, with 7.7 murders per 100,000 people.
In 2010, Frederick County's rate was 1.3 murders. (source: Maryland State Police)
In 1980, police charged or identified the culprit in 72 percent of cases nationally.
In 2008, police charged or identified the culprit in 63 percent of homicides nationally.
In a survey of cold case units, the greatest factors in solving a cold case are DNA evidence, fingerprint evidence and new witness information (source: National Institute of Justice, Cold Case Strategies report 2011)
(8) comments
Two of the MOST COWARDLY acts of homicide I've ever read about! These simply didn't need to happen! Don't think I recall the Josh Crawford case but this sounds like a case that could be solved with a big cash reward. I'll bet there was more than one person and even though two or more people may have a pact mentality at the moment of committing a crime EVERYONES "friendships" can be tested with the stands of time! With criminals it's pretty routine to have a common goal one minute and then get stepped on by the same person the next minute and that's when those reward dollars look REALLY good!!! I do remember seeing the Tracey Kirkpatrick Case on Unsolved Mysteries. It's been a long time but I seem to remember the cops said they got a call from someone saying they should be looking for someone named Dan or Dave and they were only calling because they knew there were lots of Dans or Daves in Frederick or something??? I can't remember for sure but thought the info could be worth mentioning for those that might not have seen it on TV. Maybe i've watched too much CSI shows but I don't recall many cases involving knives that aren't personal and the victim didn't know the killers(which I think is true in both these cases). Take into account the girl was 17 working TWO jobs to save for college, how many and what enemies outside of her circle could she really have??? They said they don't think robbery was a motive and as crazy as it sounds even hardend criminals don't "usually" kill young kids like that when robbery or something perverse isn't involved, much less with a knife??? I bet it's probably someone that was in the same age group. What about an ex lover or someone she may have been a threat to competitively at work or school??? The store she worked at doesn't seem like there could be that many co workers and I think Brunswick is listed as a 1A school so I doubt the student body was very big numerically. I'm pretty sure the cops would've already investigated this stuff(atleast I HOPE SO) but ya never know what can trigger or jar someones memory and many cases(especially cold cases) are usually solved by the PUBLIC getting involved! I honestly believe THESE TWO CASES CAN BE SOLVED AND SOMEONE out there(possibly reading this right now) is holding the key to both of these!
As I recall from all of the articles, Tracey was closing alone, and she most likely had locked the front door. That someone got in led the police to believe she knew her attacker and let them in. There was a big "todo" over HS students closing alone after that. I can't remember the name, but the lead detective I believe continued to pursue the case after retirement, because the police were pretty certain who it was, but short of a confession, they could not prove it. Forensics were pretty primitive then. I am pretty certain there were a couple of phone calls with the suspect in subsequent years, off the grid, but could not entice them in. I may be totally wrong, it was so long ago. Really shook up the whole county, not just Brunswick, due to the circumstances. A lot of parents started watching their kids work schedules and the the procedures of a particular busn. their kids may be working at.
That's another thing I thought was suspect too, was the time. It said she was alive at 8:45 and found about 2 hours later. Who goes to a store to see a girl at closing time that would make her comfortable enough to open the door??? boyfriend or employee claiming they forgot something maybe??? Or what about a cop, or security guard in uniform??? Guess anythings possible but if it was after hours and the door was locked for the night there's only a few people that I could see having a LEGITIMATE excuse to get in that couldn't wait tiil she had left for the night. Again i'm no super sleuth and I could be way off track here but i'm actually pretty good at solving cases on the ID channel before the ending. I would have to agree the cops probably have the persons name that did this right on the tip of the tongue.
My thoughts and prayers go out to both of these families. I can’t imagine what you have been through. I agree with jswalker what you said is very well versed. It is hard enough to except death under any circumstances, but to lose a loved one in such a violent way and never have the person responsible for it held accountable would be unbearable.
I have always wondered how someone could take another person life and be able to live with their self. How can they do that? I pray that both of these families will be able to move forward. Your life has already been affected by this tragedy, please do not let it control you (I know easier said than done) but you have other children and you have grandchildren live for them, because they need you.
I do believe that even if they catch the person/persons who are responsible it may not bring you the peace you are looking for. Life has dealt you a terrible tragedy and you have survived. My thoughts and prayers are with each one of you. May God Bless you and watch over you.
The reward at the end of the road will be much smaller than what these families anticipate.
Sadly what these families will find out if their cases are ever solved is that there will be no satisfaction. As much as they want justice for the crime, as they deserve, these crimes if solved will yield nothing that will truly make them feel any better. The only thing that could
ever give them the happiness they seek is the one thing they can never have: The murdered loved one back with them again.
Thank you FNP for this article to remind the public of these unsolved cases. I went to HS with Tracey and Deonda, and being the small HS we were, everybody knew everyone, whether you socialized with them or not. I followed the case quite a bit, and it always seemed like the police knew who likely did it, but they could not prove it. Tracey is a reminder to all of these stores hiring young people they should not let them open and close alone.
I was the manager at the Bank of Brunswick branch in Point of Rocks when Ms. Kirkpatrick was killed. We had a fund set up there for the family's expenses. I'll never forget the forlorn, hollow look Mr. Kirkpatrick had when he came into the bank to help set it up. It was devastating to see how much had been taken from this man. He looked like he had had his soul ripped out.
I would think that having a loved one murdered guts one incomprehensibly, and to know the killer was never brought to justice must be a lifelong burden. It must be nearly impossible to live a normal life after such a tragedy and travesty. My heart aches for any family that has to bear this burden.
We all have to die, and living with the loss of a loved one is difficult enough as we all know. To know that some monster has cut the life of your loved one short, the potential that will never be realized, the enjoyable times that will never happen, the grandchildren that will never come into your life...Simply incomprehensible.
^ Powerful words. I stand with you, jswalker.
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Keep it clean. No vulgar, racist, sexist or sexually-oriented language.
Engage ideas. This forum is for the exchange of ideas, not personal attacks or ad hominem criticisms.
TURN OFF CAPS LOCK.
Be civil. Don't threaten. Don't lie. Don't bait. Don't degrade others.
No trolling. Stay on topic.
No spamming. This is not the place to sell miracle cures.
No deceptive names. Apparently misleading usernames are not allowed.
Say it once. No repetitive posts, please.
Help us. Use the 'Report' link for abusive posts.