For a few hours Wednesday morning, a small corner of Emmitsburg looked just as it did in 1927.

The town’s “doughboy” statue, scrubbed and repaired, was laboriously placed atop a new, 6-ton limestone pedestal in the statue’s original location in front of the historic Emmit House. The limestone came from the same Indiana quarry that provided the statue’s original base before it was erected in 1927.

“Doughboy” was a colloquial name for an infantryman during World War I. The statue depicts a soldier with a rifle in one hand and a grenade in the other. It stood in front of the house at 601 W. Main St. in Emmitsburg until it was hit by a truck in June.

Dianne Walbrecker lives a few yards away from the doughboy statue. She was sitting on her front porch with her daughter minutes before the crash.

It was a foggy, rainy night, she remembers. She had just gone into the house and turned on the faucet in the kitchen. Her daughter came to tell her that “someone crashed into the doughboy.”

Walbrecker ran outside with a flashlight and a blanket, and saw that a woman driving a truck had hit the statue. The stone pedestal was damaged, and the statue had toppled over.

Walbrecher called 911 and sat on the curb with the dazed driver until an ambulance took the woman away.

Months later, the town is still waiting to hear from the driver’s insurance company. The town commissioners voted to spend $40,000 to repair the statue.

To re-solder the statue’s halves together, and to obtain a new limestone base, the town hired Gary Casteel, a Gettysburg resident and Vietnam War veteran.

He watched as the statue went up Wednesday morning.

Casteel noted that many similar doughboy statues around the country have turned green or black with age. Emmitsburg’s doughboy has been restored to its original copper color.

“It will brighten the west end of Emmitsburg,” he said.

Five men and a crane stacked the three limestone pedestal pieces, then the statue, in their original place.

“It’s a lot of manual labor and time involved, but once it’s up, it’s there for many generations,” Casteel said.

The original plaque, which stirred some controversy in the town, is unchanged. The plaque lists three veterans’ names under the heading “Colored Soldiers.”

On the same June night the statue was knocked off its pedestal, a shooting at an African Methodist Episcopal church in Charleston, South Carolina, left nine people dead.

The shooting prompted Emmitsburg resident Bob Rosensteel to call for a plaque for the statue that does not refer to race, but lists the names alphabetically.

At town meetings since then, and while the statue was going up, local veterans defended the “Colored Soldiers” heading.

Thomas Hoke, a longtime Emmitsburg resident who served as an Army combat medic during World War II, said the wording on the plaque shouldn’t change.

“That’s the way it was back in those days, and that’s the way it should stay,” he said.

Mike Humerick, an Air Force veteran and former Emmitsburg resident, said in front of the Emmit House on Wednesday that he was surprised people disagreed about the wording.

“That thing has been that way for years,” he said. “Why do they want to change it?”

Though the town’s commissioners wondered whether another plaque should be added to acknowledge the reference, they ultimately decided to put the statue back up with just the original plaque.

Humerick, Hoke, Walbrecker, Casteel and the town’s mayor, Don Briggs, were all happy to see the statue back in place.

“It means so much to the community,” Briggs said. “It’ll be a really special little place again.”

Follow Sylvia Carignan on Twitter: @SylviaCarignan.

(6) comments


That wording was acceptable from 1927 until sometime in the early 70's. Times change and our standards change with them but society cannot go back and alter history to fit with the current political tides. If we do that every time, then our past changes from history to "his"story (PE,1991).


WHEN THE OPPORTUNITY ARISES to CORRECT an ugly and ignorant display CHANGE it. Again, lack of social skills and evolution.


Why are they still waiting to hear from the insurance company? They town needs to go after them if they aren't responding.


Perhaps your position is due to a lack of social skills and blood flow. Another proud moment for Emmitsburg. Hopeless.


The wording colored was put there to honor the black soldiers, not to denigrate them. So, I really do not understand all the controversy.


I'm at a loss too. If the now-archaic term "colored" were removed and those names shuffled in with the others, then someone would complain about that. If those who spent so much time and energy on finding something to be offended by would concentrate on real problems, just imagine what they could accomplish.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it clean. No vulgar, racist, sexist or sexually-oriented language.
Engage ideas. This forum is for the exchange of ideas, not personal attacks or ad hominem criticisms.
Be civil. Don't threaten. Don't lie. Don't bait. Don't degrade others.
No trolling. Stay on topic.
No spamming. This is not the place to sell miracle cures.
No deceptive names. Apparently misleading usernames are not allowed.
Say it once. No repetitive posts, please.
Help us. Use the 'Report' link for abusive posts.

Thank you for reading!

Already a member?

Login Now
Click Here!

Currently a News-Post subscriber?

Activate your membership at no additional charge.
Click Here!

Need more information?

Learn about the benefits of membership.
Click Here!

Ready to join?

Choose the membership plan that fits your needs.
Click Here!