When the Safeway supermarket on West Seventh Street closed this past spring after more than 30 years in that location, the number of easily accessible grocery options for downtown residents took a significant hit.

That dynamic could soon change, though, as representatives from a local grocer look to expand to the roughly 40,700-square-foot space in the College Park Plaza Shopping Center.

Bob Thompson, general manager of Common Market on Buckeystown Pike, said on Tuesday that the company is moving ahead on opening a second, member-owned natural foods store at the West Seventh Street location.

“We’re putting all of our efforts into the Safeway [site]. We’re trying to make this happen,” he said.

It’s no secret that Common Market representatives have been looking to open another store closer to downtown. Last year, they were eyeing the old Carmack-Jay’s site on North Market Street, but Thompson said over the summer those plans had fizzled. With the focus narrowed to only the Safeway building, Thompson said he could have some news to share in 30 to 45 days.

“It’s looking very promising right now,” he said. “By the end of January we should have a really good idea about where we are.”

Thompson explained that a few hurdles need to be cleared to finalize an expansion to the site, which include figuring the cost of retrofitting the building, making sure everything is feasible, and ensuring members of the company’s co-op are on board.

“We can sell stock in our company to try and raise money,” Thompson said of the conversations that he needs to have with co-op members.

Old Safeway

The former Safeway store in the College Park Plaza Shopping Center on West Seventh Street.

Mayor Michael O’Connor said on Tuesday that the potential for Common Market to come to the Safeway site is a good thing for the city, even though it is not downtown.

“It’s exciting to know Common Market is looking at another site in the city,” he said. “That’s a vacant storefront that the community was concerned about.”

And although the idea that a much-needed food store could be coming downtown was an exciting prospect when the Carmack-Jay’s site was on the table, Thompson said the Safeway site — still close to downtown and within walking distance for many residents — was ultimately more feasible and desirable.

“The Safeway store currently is a grocery store, or was a grocery store. It has all of the updated power and all of the floor drains, and all of the safety equipment is there. That wasn’t [so] in the Carmack-Jay’s building,” Thompson explained. “The construction costs are actually less for us to do what we have to do to get the store open.”

Thompson declined to offer a price range for the construction costs because he plans to bid out the jobs. He also said the company plans to purchase the building as part of the expansion, but he would not discuss prices.

Thompson pointed out as well that the building is twice the size of the Buckeystown Pike store — although he expects the same sales volume — and added that employees are tossing around a lot of ideas for it that the current store does not offer.

“The store will just be bigger. We’re going to have a bakery in the store. We’ve never had [one] before,” he said. “We’re looking to potentially be able to do organic catering. ... Some of this is preliminary, but we’ve been talking a pizza kitchen, a burrito station.”

And while Common Market is different from Safeway or other grocery chains in terms of affordability given that mostly organic food is sold, Thompson said shoppers of all income levels will still be able to shop there.

“We’re not going to be able to price Heinz ketchup the way Wegmans is — first of all, because we’re not going to have Heinz ketchup — but will we have affordable options for food? Yes,” Thompson said.

Connie Ray, manager of the Frederick Food Security Network at Hood College, said the loss of the Safeway was a blow to the downtown area, as it created what is known as a food desert.

In a food desert, she explained, a certain percentage of people living below the federal poverty line do not have access to viable food options.

“Within a food desert typically people end up shopping at corner stores, convenience stores, which vary on what they carry,” Ray said.

To determine food deserts that exist locally, Ray said the Frederick Food Security Network used a half-mile radius because most people cannot walk farther than that with groceries. While the Safeway was operating, it was within walking range to many parts of downtown. Therefore, if a Common Market opens at the site, it could eliminate the food desert.

While Ray expressed some concerns about the affordability of Common Market in comparison with other food stores, she said she has met with store representatives and believe they will work to address that.

“It’s something that they are aware of, and I believe they are working to make that affordable for those people,” she said.

Follow Mallory Panuska on Twitter: @MalloryPanuska.

(24) comments


Another reason for the artists to not live downtown, rents are high and this will be the closest grocery store.


This is great news! A bigger parking lot so it's more accessible than downtown. But still within walking distance from the apartments and homes nearby.


Wonderful news! Between Wegmans and Common Market, I am in grocery heaven!


FNP where's the story about a Massachusetts company, Curaleaf, offering $30 million to a "Small Frederick company" for the rights to grow and distribute medical marijuana? It was in today's Sun. Heck, it's our back yard Mr. Wilson and not one mention of this? Crazy.


"Mayor Michael O’Connor said on Tuesday that the potential for Common Market to come to the Safeway site is a good thing for the city, even though it is not downtown."

It needs to be downtown. This is a lost opportunity and the Mayor needs to sweeten the post for Common Market for the 4th street location. If not, tear it down and build condos. 20 years vacant is to long.


If you want it downtown then come up $3 million to make it happen. Your verbal flatulence wont make it happen


The display photo looks nice.


There are quite a few grocery stores in the area... Frederick is not really "dry" when it comes to a grocery store except for true "downtown"... but anyone in that area can still get to a grocery store relatively easy or have food delivery. I love the Common Market for it's local roots; I just hope they can get enough business to sustain a store that large. They may need to consider food offering options that are more affordable than pricing at current store. I want them to succeed.


I love Common Market for its high-quality produce and locally farmed meat and poultry. It’s definitely more expensive than Safeway, though.

The Grape of Wrath

These niche stores are all just high-priced hype. First of all notice the "Organic" banner in the photo. Like Whole Foods, commonly known as Whole Check because that's what it takes to shop there, overplays the phony baloney "Organic" label to the hilt. "Organic" means 'We charge you double because we know you're dumb enough to believe anything with organic on the label is somehow better and will pay more." Who would buy anything from that Bozos-run outfit anyway, where they treat prime buyers like royalty and non-prime buyers like sheet?


If you don't like it, don't shop there.


Well, just like everything else that offends your ears, eyes or pocketbook.....change the channel, switch stations or just SHOP SOMEWHERE ELSE! I’m not a fan of Bezos but that won’t keep me from shopping healthy.


Have you ever even been inside the Common Market? It's an entirely local business that has survived and grown over the years and has a loyal base. If you think the whole thing is BS, go in there and buy 1 bottle of Trickling Springs chocolate milk and it will change your life. Maybe visit the website to see all the local vendors. Or maybe just keep shopping for groceries Walmart, which is really convenient because they also sell sweatpants.


Love this comment! You are totally right about the TS chocolate milk, and the sweatpants part was hilarious. Thank you for the well-written laugh!


Sweatpants FTW!


Comparing Whole Foods to Common Market is ridiculous. Common Market is a local co-op. You can buy shares ow ownership, you're supporting local businesses, not just the Common Market but their local suppliers which are mostly farms. "Organic" or not I'd rather buy produce from the local area for it's freshness and taste and support of my local economy.


Myself, I`m going up to Shuff`s tomorrow and buy me some of those Pork chops. Yum yum[beam]with a side of raw Mooo Moo meat! unmm.....cant`t wait.


But...But...But...according to the “Principal” you should be shopping at the 7-11!


Get the story straight. The Carmack-Jay building has been sitting empty for 30 years.


And should be demolished. It is too outdated, behind code and an eyesore. Wonder if the city is still collecting taxes on that building from the owner?


It should be demolished and rebuilt up on the street, put the parking in the back.


Mallory states it was occupied until 1998 by Tesoro. If you mean just Carmack Jay, you probably are right, but the statement was occupancy.


Ok 20 years. Hardly long a all....


I moved downtown in '97 and shopped at Tesoro. (It was terrible, I would drive to Martin's on 7th st.) The building might be better suited to be a large restaurant than a grocery store.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it clean. No vulgar, racist, sexist or sexually-oriented language.
Engage ideas. This forum is for the exchange of ideas, not personal attacks or ad hominem criticisms.
Be civil. Don't threaten. Don't lie. Don't bait. Don't degrade others.
No trolling. Stay on topic.
No spamming. This is not the place to sell miracle cures.
No deceptive names. Apparently misleading usernames are not allowed.
Say it once. No repetitive posts, please.
Help us. Use the 'Report' link for abusive posts.

Thank you for reading!

Already a member?

Login Now
Click Here!

Currently a News-Post subscriber?

Activate your membership at no additional charge.
Click Here!

Need more information?

Learn about the benefits of membership.
Click Here!

Ready to join?

Choose the membership plan that fits your needs.
Click Here!