BG Butterfly Lane Aerial - MP (copy)

Butterfly Lane passes between the Prospect Hall Apartments and the Hargett Farm and future Westview Park.

No ground has been broken on the amenities of Frederick’s long-anticipated Westside Regional Park, yet city taxpayers are already on the hook for millions of dollars and could end up dedicating roughly $40,000 more before dirt begins to move.

That was one of several takeaways of a lengthy and slightly heated Board of Aldermen workshop held on Wednesday to showcase recommendations from an ad hoc task force on the next steps toward developing the park.

The project is set to include an array of amenities that could range from top-level sports fields to a swimming complex and ice rink, on 136 acres of vacant, city-owned property along Butterfly Lane known as Hargett Farm.

The 11-member task force spent a little more than a year discussing elements of a proposed master park plan, engaging members of the community, and conducting research that included site visits to other successful facilities and picking the brains of industry experts.

The group’s recommendations included establishing a mission statement on the park’s goal as a regional destination, residential recreational space and local economic driver.

“This park has the potential to be a lot of things to a lot of people,” said Bob Smith, the city’s deputy director of parks and recreation. “Obviously, we want this park to be a benefit to members of the community.”

Members also recommended some minor changes to the initial master plan and the creation of a permanent group to continue research, including determining the project’s financing and budget, and exploring possible funding partners.

And while the aldermen agreed that the recommendations are good, and gave the go-ahead to move forward with them, a few expressed concerns about some details of the process.

After hearing from two members of the task force during Wednesday’s public comment period, Alderman Ben MacShane expressed frustration over why an option to work with the Maryland Stadium Authority to help develop the park was not mentioned during the previous nearly two hours of the workshop.

“My frustration is that seemingly we were very much approaching the end of this workshop and I needed to ask a question brought to my mind by public comment about why the stadium authority isn’t on board,” MacShane said after hearing from task force members Debbie Reynolds and Ed Hinde.

Reynolds and Hinde encouraged the aldermen to consider bringing the stadium authority on board. Mayor Michael O’Connor said that the idea may be the best option going forward, but said officials have demanded an economic study that would cost roughly $40,000. He said that figure made him hesitant to mention the option at the regular workshop.

“I heard from a majority of this Board of Aldermen over the last year ... that there was little appetite to put more public money into this project,” he said. “So if you think I’m going to sit here under those circumstances and propose that we put more public money into this project when a majority of you through a campaign said we don’t want to put more public money into the project — yeah, you’re right, I’m going to sit on that little piece of information until I hear what the room has to say about it. You bet.”

He added that the workshop was not held to discuss specific proposals, but to give members of the task force a chance to present their recommendations and finish their work.

“The purpose of this workshop was to bring you an update of what the task force has had a conversation about and get your concurrence that we want to continue to move forward down this path,” he said.

From there, the aldermen determined that the next step is following through on the recommendations, namely the efforts to find funding partners, which they agreed should come from a request for information or proposal process.

Alderwoman Kelly Russell said she understands MacShane’s frustration with the stadium authority situation. She said that gathering information for the proposal needs to be part of the next steps, and she reiterated her desire not to spend any more tax dollars on the project at this time, but said an economic impact study could be beneficial.

Alderwoman Donna Kuzemchak, the aldermanic liaison of the task force, said she also understands MacShane’s point about the stadium authority and admitted she has also had many frustrations since the inception of the project years ago.

Aldermen Roger Wilson and Derek Shackelford both expressed a desire to move forward as quickly as possible on finding funding partners and establishing a clear development plan for the site. Shackelford pointed out that the longer the officials wait to pin down the money, the more money the city is racking up on debt service on the land.

The aldermen are not required to officially vote on the recommendations of the task force members, and O’Connor said the next step is establishing the next group and its mission.

Follow Mallory Panuska on Twitter:


(6) comments


This park idea and the new hotel/convention center are both going to cost the taxpayers and are loser ideas?????????


“I heard from a majority of this Board of Aldermen over the last year ... that there was little appetite to put more public money into this project,” he said. He wants to protect us from spending 40K but how much is he giving away to the Plamondons for a hotel many of us taxpayers don't support? The city just annexed land to be used for industrial. Instead of taking in new property, why not use the Butterfly Lane property for that purpose? A recreational area on Butterfly Lane is not going to produce revenue. It will always be a liability due to costs for maintenance, insurance, employees (lifeguards, etc.). Sell that property as quickly as possible!


Use the Hargett Farm for industry? Are you serious? It is surrounded by thousands of homes. A good park makes total sense. It is true, that revenue generated by the park will be minimal, but not everything is measured in dollars. Find funding partners and get it done Mayor Mike.


The Jefferson"tech" park is surrounded by homes too. So far that is all you will find at the "tech" park. As to funding the ill-advised recreational center on Butterfly Lane, ask the Plamondons to fund it.


I agree that the "tech" park is anything but "tech". I have been against it and the ill conceived downtown hotel, from the beginning. Sincerely doubt the Plamondon clan will fund the Westside regional park as there is nothing to be gained for them financially. But hey, maybe they'd earn something as they own 2 Roy Rogers within a 1.5 mile radius. People have to eat.


Easy fix just take the 136 acres and SNAPSHOT it into 1,200 homes and call it Benjamin Bluff! complete with infrastructure.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it clean. No vulgar, racist, sexist or sexually-oriented language.
Engage ideas. This forum is for the exchange of ideas, not personal attacks or ad hominem criticisms.
Be civil. Don't threaten. Don't lie. Don't bait. Don't degrade others.
No trolling. Stay on topic.
No spamming. This is not the place to sell miracle cures.
No deceptive names. Apparently misleading usernames are not allowed.
Say it once. No repetitive posts, please.
Help us. Use the 'Report' link for abusive posts.

Thank you for reading!

Already a member?

Login Now
Click Here!

Currently a News-Post subscriber?

Activate your membership at no additional charge.
Click Here!

Need more information?

Learn about the benefits of membership.
Click Here!

Ready to join?

Choose the membership plan that fits your needs.
Click Here!