The Derby

The Derby restaurant on West Main Street in New Market is hoping to increase its seating capacity.

The Derby restaurant in New Market has a seating capacity of 231, yet it is almost always filled.

Drive by on a Friday or Saturday night, or a weeknight on a special occasion, and customers will be lining the bar and sitting on the patio enjoying a meal out with family and friends.

The restaurant at 83 W. Main St. has been so popular that after being open for only nine months, the owners are ready to expand.

Staci Caiola, who owns the restaurant with her husband, Dan, attended the town’s Planning and Zoning Commission meeting last week with hopes of adding seating to the upstairs space of the restaurant and open up the lawn for events.

For outdoor events, the owners plan to have movie nights where people bring their own chairs or blankets. For concerts, bands would set up on the porch and tables and chairs would be set up on the grass.

A recent event with a similar setup brought out about 200 people, which Staci Caiola called “a good number regarding space.”

For additional seating, the owners want to open the upstairs space of the property. It’s currently being used for storage, but the Caiolas want to use it for private parties and extra seating on Friday and Saturday nights, if the room isn’t rented.

A bar will not be added upstairs.

The fire marshal has not been in the space to determine its maximum occupancy, but Caiola estimated that 40 to 50 people would be a comfortable number for parties such as bridal and baby showers and sports team parties.

“We’re getting a ton of requests for those types of parties,” Caiola told the Planning and Zoning Commission. “Right now they’re just mixed into the dining area or we’ve put them out back. We had a team party this week that sat outside at picnic tables.”

To utilize the upstairs and increase the service area in the restaurant, the town’s Board of Appeals must issue an amendment to the current special exception approval that is in place. The special exception, which was grandfathered in when the Caiolas took over the building, allows the property to have a restaurant, according to Pat Faux, town planner and zoning administrator.

Town code stipulates that the Planning and Zoning Commission see a site plan for the property once the owners get their Board of Appeals approval. The commission will also need a site plan to add parking, which the town thinks should be tackled first.

“The biggest thing I see is they’re already at capacity for parking,” said Dennis Kimble, Town Council liaison for the commission. “I like The Derby. They’re doing a great job there, and I would like to see them expand because they’re improving the town. But they need to increase that parking area. They’re already over the limit.”

He suggested a parking study be done before going to the Board of Appeals to determine how many parking spots are needed given the amount of seating in the restaurant.

The restaurant has about 20 designated parking spots, Caiola said. Along with street parking, the fire department across the street offered parking spaces in their lot to the restaurant, although she did not know how many spots would be offered, she said.

Faux added that the town code on parking “is a very creative one” that allows applicants to propose alternative parking solutions, such as using the fire department’s parking lot.

But added parking for the restaurant concerns nearby businesses.

Gayla Wheeler, owner of Gayla’s, which is next door to The Derby, is concerned about the stormwater runoff from the restaurant’s current parking lot as well as customers taking all of the street parking.

“Even if the street accommodates The Derby, it does take away from the existing businesses,” she told the commission. “Some people aren’t coming to go to The Derby. They’re coming to go to one of the shops.”

She suggested that the commission consider the limited parking for nearby businesses and the current drainage problem due to stormwater runoff.

“They’ve got three businesses going there now,” she said. “The restaurant, the tavern and the ice cream parlor, and now they want to add the upstairs, which is a concern to me because of the noise level increases.”

To tackle the parking issue before any site plans are drawn up, Kimble made a motion for a parking study to be conducted and for the findings to be brought to the Board of Appeals. A second motion was added that one of the planning board members go to the Board of Appeals to present the recommendations for their consideration.

A Board of Appeals meeting has not yet been scheduled.

Follow CJ Fairfield on Twitter:


(3) comments


Gayla Wheeler said '“They’ve got three businesses going there now,” she said. “The restaurant, the tavern and the ice cream parlor, and now they want to add the upstairs, which is a concern to me because of the noise level increases.” So I wonder if Ms. Wheeler would mind so much if the increased noise was coming from her establishment due to increased patronage? I dont think so. If the Derby is taking your business, maybe you need to change your business model to one that draws customers. Sheesh.


Gayla's is a jewelry/antique shop. i highly doubt a restaurant is "taking their business"


The Derby is the only cool thing in New Market. If they want a space ship on the front lawn, give it to them.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Engage ideas. This forum is for the exchange of ideas, insights and experiences, not personal attacks. Ad hominen criticisms are not allowed. Focus on ideas instead.
Don't threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
No trolls. Off-topic comments and comments that bait others are not allowed.
No spamming. This is not the place to sell miracle cures.
Say it once. No repeat or repetitive posts, please.
Help us. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.