Frederick County was one of 13 counties in the state that saw none of its public schools receive below a three-star rating on the 2019 Maryland school report cards.

The ratings and other data, which were released Tuesday, assess the quality of all 1,400 public schools in the state. Scores are given based on factors such as achievement on state tests, graduation rates and the results of surveys taken by students and teachers.

Frederick County had eight schools receive three-star ratings, 37 schools receive four-star ratings and 16 schools receive five-star ratings.

See where your school ranked on Maryland State Report cards

See where your school ranked in the 2019 Maryland report cards.

Field 1 Field 2 Field 3
School Stars Percentile Rank
Elementary
Ballenger Creek 4 59
Brunswick 4 44
Butterfly Ridge 3 13
Carroll Manor 4 83
Centerville 5 96
Deer Crossing 4 83
Emmitsburgh 4 66
Glade 4 84
Green Valley 4 63
Hillcrest 3 39
Kemptown 5 95
Lewistown 4 80
Liberty 4 65
Lincoln 4 56
Middletown 4 76
Monocacy 4 62
Myersville 5 84
New Market 5 94
New Midway/Woodsboro 4 66
North Frederick 4 58
Oakdale 4 80
Orchard Grove 4 48
Parkway 4 76
Sabillasville 5 92
Spring Ridge 4 67
Thurmont 4 51
Tuscarora 4 55
Twin Ridge 4 61
Urbana 5 91
Valley 5 88
Walkersville 4 45
Waverley 4 62
Whittier 4 78
Wolfsville 5 89
Yellow Springs 4 75
Middle
Ballenger Creek 3 56
Brunswick 4 69
Crestwood 3 50
TJ 3 61
Middletown 4 89
Monocacy 3 42
New Market 4 88
Oakdale 4 91
Thurmont 4 71
Urbana 4 91
Walkersville 4 65
West Frederick 4 73
Windsor Knolls 4 90
Elementary/Middle
Carrol Creek Montessori 5 77 (Elementary), 99 (Middle)
Frederick Classical Charter 5 91 (Elementary), 95 (Middle)
Monocacy Valley Montessori 5 76 (Elementary), 99 (Middle)
High
Brunswick 4 73
Catoctin 4 66
Frederick 3 46
TJ 3 40
Linganore 5 94
Middletown 5 96
Oakdale 5 96
Tuscarora 4 70
Urbana 5 92
Walkersville 5 83

Frederick County Public Schools Superintendent Terry Alban said in an email that she appreciates the efforts of students and staff to produce such high scores.

“As a district, we continuously perform in the top quartile in the state. To achieve three stars or above in every school is commendable,” Alban said.

Some of the highest-scoring schools at each level were Centerville Elementary School, Urbana Middle School and Middletown High School. Each received five stars and had high academic proficiency ratings.

This is the second year of the star-rating system, which came into effect due to a requirement set by the Every Student Succeeds Act, which replaced the No Child Left Behind Act in 2015. Many other states have similar rating systems to Maryland’s that give either a star rating or letter grade.

State Superintendent of Schools Karen Salmon said in a statement that she hopes the report cards will help provide transparency and critical information to all public school stakeholders.

“We hope this will help everyone gain a better understanding of how each school is doing, and provide inspiration about how we can work together to make our schools the best they can be for all students,” Salmon said.

Although Frederick had a high number of five-star schools, not one middle school in the county received the top score. Four of the county’s 13 middle schools received three stars, and the rest received four. This count does not include the three public charter schools in the county. 

When asked if this was cause for concern, Alban said that academic performance at the middle school level continues to be a focus and that while there were no five-star ratings, FCPS middle schools did improve their performance overall compared with others in the state.

The lowest-scoring school in the district was Butterfly Ridge Elementary. The school on the west side of Frederick received three stars, but ranked only in the 13th percentile compared with other elementary schools across Maryland.

Additionally, the school reported only 16 percent proficiency in math and 23 percent proficiency in English Language Arts.

Alban said this did not come as a surprise as much of the data had previously been reported and that she and staff have been working with school administrators for several months to develop improvement plans.

“Central leaders have identified Comprehensive Improvement Plans for our schools that we recognize need to significantly improve their academic performance. ... Butterfly Ridge has been identified as one of those schools,” Alban said, adding that there is “no simple answer” for improving academic performance.

“The root cause will vary from school to school and therefore, the approach to improve will be similar but different at each school,” she said.

When asked how she feels, overall, about the star rating system Alban said she has “never been a fan” of trying to describe the performance of a school so simplistically and that she feels the system puts more focus on rankings than anything else.

“[The rating] is easily misinterpreted because it appears so simple and yet it is so complex,” Alban said. “The reason one school gets four stars and one school gets five stars varies from school to school depending on the indicators and how the comparisons are done.”

However, the complexity of the indicators is good, said Alban, because it means the ratings are derived from multiple measures instead of something simple and standardized like test scores. This complex data can then be used effectively by the school system.

“This report card provides a lot of valuable information that our schools can unpack to determine the best next steps,” Alban said.

She also encouraged parents and students to follow FCPS and fully unpack the data for their school instead of just looking at the star rating.

“I would remind parents that the report card cannot tell us everything about a school, so be cautious in how you interpret the star ratings,” Alban said. “The star ratings are the ‘tip of the iceberg.’”

Follow Katryna Perera on Twitter: @katrynajill.

(10) comments

kellimcintosh

Thank you for adding the charter schools to the chart online - a correction should be printed in the paper explaining that they were omitted from the original article.

The article still erroneously states that no middle schools received 5 stars. Actually, all three charter schools earned 5 stars for their middle school students.

Greg F

Being trained to take tests is not achievement. I've seen some of the most moronic students come out of Frederick County schools that even do not (out of high school) understand that the earth revolves around the sun nor have a basic understanding of science and math. It's pathetic how these ratings are overblown. Athletics far outweighs academics in the schools I know.

CapsFan10

Interesting that all 3 charter schools scored 5 stars but no mention here. It's not true that Frederick did not have any 5 star middle schools.......it had 3 and they are all charter schools. Those schools receive less funding, must admit students based on a random lottery, and Frederick Classical is more diverse than most Frederick County schools but they still consistently outscore the county.

https://reportcard.msde.maryland.gov/Graphs/#/ReportCards/ReportCardSchool/1/EM/1/10/1301/

https://reportcard.msde.maryland.gov/Graphs/#/ReportCards/ReportCardSchool/1/EM/1/10/0228/

https://reportcard.msde.maryland.gov/Graphs/#/ReportCards/ReportCardSchool/1/EM/1/10/0228/

riccicc

Scoring high on a lower standard basis is nothing to brag. I know too many of the students with a high school diploma cannot do well with high school level material. As far as I'm concerned, those diplomas from those individuals are fraudulent (although, the student is not at fault for that, it's the system's fault) and that means to me the system has issued fraudulent high school diplomas, in those cases. I won't hire anybody unless they can pass an entrance exam, of which many cannot pass, unfortunately.

Dragon314

How can FCPS have higher marks when they aren’t allowed to give F’s or fail students? Elementary, Middle School, and High Schools follow a broken system.

marinick1

[thumbup]

butterflygirl

This ranking of schools has nothing to do with student grades.

riccicc

I'm afraid it's got everything to do with the student and the grades. With ESSA and NCLB requirements, the student's success with grades is the school's success and that's what is reflected in these so called ratings. But as I said earlier, high scores on an even lower standard basis is nothing to brag.

riccicc

[thumbup][thumbup][thumbup]

summertime

I'm not sure what this comment is based on. Students do receive F's and fail. When my daughter missed several weeks of school due to hospitalization for a life-threatening illness, she failed and had to retake a class.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it clean. No vulgar, racist, sexist or sexually-oriented language.
Engage ideas. This forum is for the exchange of ideas, not personal attacks or ad hominem criticisms.
TURN OFF CAPS LOCK.
Be civil. Don't threaten. Don't lie. Don't bait. Don't degrade others.
No trolling. Stay on topic.
No spamming. This is not the place to sell miracle cures.
No deceptive names. Apparently misleading usernames are not allowed.
Say it once. No repetitive posts, please.
Help us. Use the 'Report' link for abusive posts.

Thank you for reading!

Already a member?

Login Now
Click Here!

Currently a News-Post subscriber?

Activate your membership at no additional charge.
Click Here!

Need more information?

Learn about the benefits of membership.
Click Here!

Ready to join?

Choose the membership plan that fits your needs.
Click Here!