Frederick County Public Schools will be closed on Yom Kippur and Election Day during the 2018-2019 school year.

The Frederick County Board of Education backtracked on its proposed calendar late Wednesday night and instead approved the original recommended calendar brought to them by the calendar committee.

The accepted calendar combines Fair Day and Yom Kippur on the same dates, as opposed to having the traditional Fair Friday.

Board member Ken Kerr said even though he wanted to have Fair Friday, the calendar just didn’t have enough days to make that possible.

“We just can’t make it work. Whenever we can make it work, we will make it work,” Kerr said. “There’s a saying that the best deal is the one where both sides feel a little bad, and that’s what we have here. Both sides are walking away feeling a little bad.”

April Miller was the only board member to oppose the calendar. Fellow member Colleen Cusimano was not present at the time of the vote.

The calendar also includes moving a two-hour early dismissal day that was originally slated in February to a two-hour early dismissal on the day before Thanksgiving, Nov. 21.

The day before Election Day is a teacher workday, after the proposed plan had Election Day as the teacher workday.

FCPS employees will not be able to attend a popular professional development day that many districts throughout the state attend that is held on Oct. 19, because school is open on that day. Instead, teachers will get an added professional development day on Aug. 24.

Parent teacher conferences are slated for Nov. 5 through Nov. 9.

The board made the decision last month to close school on Sept. 21 for Fair Day. The original recommendation consolidated both days on Sept. 19, but the board had no data on how many students would be absent on Yom Kippur, so it sought public feedback on the calendar to see what the response would be.

The board can’t choose to close school because of religious reasons, but can close schools for days it expects high rates of absenteeism.

The 2018-2019 school year’s calendar was particularly challenging because school officials have to find several days of school they didn’t have to worry about last year. In 2017, Yom Kippur fell on a Saturday, so schools didn’t need to close. In 2018, there is a gubernatorial election, which will require schools to be closed on Election Day (Nov. 6). Finally, the last day of the school calendar, June 15, is a Saturday, which is another day the board has to account for.

The scheduling challenges have led to other school districts considering staying open on the Jewish holidays.

Charles Cramer, of The Great Frederick Fair Board, spoke in support of keeping Fair Day on Friday, saying tradition and learning opportunities were invaluable to the students in FCPS.

“We have enjoyed Fair Friday for a number of years without moving it around and joining it with another important day,” Cramer said.

Mason Kaplan, an FCPS student, advocated closing schools on Yom Kippur, because of the challenges students face to make up work if they were to miss school.

Rabbi Simon Stratford, of Congregation Kol Ami, also advocated consolidating Fair Day and Yom Kippur to the same day — Sept. 19.

Stratford said closing schools on Rosh Hashana and not Yom Kippur — the holiest day of the year — was a “slap in the face,” and that having schools closed on Good Friday, which is required by the state, is “unfortunate.”

“If Fair Week is just that, an entire week, I believe it’s a small favor to ask to consolidate those days,” Stratford said. Stratford added that the calendar can have Fair Day in following years, because Yom Kippur doesn’t always fall in the same time frame as Fair Week.

In the original calendar proposal the board had slated Election Day, Nov. 6, as a teacher workday, instead of closing schools completely.

Also, the negotiated contract with the teachers union requires teachers have 190 workdays — 10 more than students have. Four of those 10 days had been inside the student calendar. Now, only three teacher workdays fall inside the calendar, and no professional development days.

Five of the 10 workdays are teacher workdays, which teachers often use for grading. The other five days are for professional development, which teachers are required to attend.

Follow Allen Etzler on Twitter: @AllenWEtzler.

(17) comments


And PC is run amok in the small little minorities to twist and turn everything. Go back under you rocks you PC schmucks, and Board members for bowing down and bending over.


The teachers need to do their inservice days on Saturdays. Even lawyers and doctors work on Saturdays.


Good luck with that Kelly.

Comment deleted.

I am surprised that the comment was permitted but it probably captures a glimpse of the antisemitism that is starting to build in certain parts of the country and Europe. Somehow that needs to be checked or diffused. This would make an excellent court case. Does anyone really care if Yom Kippur is a day off? But the other comments are correct. What about other religious holidays? Or even pagan holidays.Preferably i would like to see some court reversals regarding Religion and schools.


Aren't there two Fair Saturdays and two Fair Sundays each year that kids can go to?


My mistake - two Saturdays but only one Sunday.


Who cares what day of the week Fair Day is? I don't remember it ever being called "Fair Friday".


I think a good point that has previously been brought up is just how many kids go to the fair when they have the day off from school to do so? I tend to think fewer and fewer do these days. So, if a student has entered something in the fair, i.e. a sheep, cow, hog, cake, etc. let them have the day off to attend and give them credit for it in school. All other kids can go to the fair either after school, on the weekends or both.


Yeah. Good solution Board.




Maybe schools should also be closed for Kwanzaa, Ramadan and Pioneer Day.


Kwanzaa runs from Dec 26-Jan 1, so the schools are closed. Pioneer day is July 24, so the schools are closed then too.


You left out St. Patrick's Day, are you prejudice against the Irish?


[thumbup] Finally something we can agree on!!!


Kwanzaa isn't a religion. It is made up.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Engage ideas. This forum is for the exchange of ideas, insights and experiences, not personal attacks. Ad hominen criticisms are not allowed. Focus on ideas instead.
Don't threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
No trolls. Off-topic comments and comments that bait others are not allowed.
No spamming. This is not the place to sell miracle cures.
Say it once. No repeat or repetitive posts, please.
Help us. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.