photo 1

Chanel Holland voices her concerns with the school redistricting plan at a public hearing Tuesday at Oakdale High School. She bought her home specifically because her kids would attend Urbana High School. Under the superintendent's plan, her kids would be moved to Linganore High School. 

Large maps, laptops and children were brought to the microphones at three public hearings held in the past week regarding the Linganore-Oakdale-Urbana (LOU) school redistricting study.

Affected families filled the three high schools in an effort to show Board of Education members the effect the superintendent's proposed plan would have on their school and personal lives.

One of the biggest arguments against Superintendent Terry Alban’s plan seemed to be that it would move large portions of students to schools that are much farther away than where they currently attend.

“I feel at some point the math got ahead of the common sense. People that live so close to a school can’t go to that school,” one mother said.

She has two children who attend Centerville Elementary School. She explained to school board members that under the proposed plan, her children would be moved to Sugarloaf Elementary School. She said Centerville Elementary is only two-tenths of a mile from her home, whereas Sugarloaf Elementary is 2 miles away.

Several other parents also reported that their children, who now walk to school, would have to take buses to their new school under Alban’s plan, which seems to contradict one of the guidelines outlined in school board policy.

According to the policy, when the school system is developing or adjusting school attendance boundary areas, numerous factors must be considered, including proximity to schools, in order to “maximize walkers and minimize distance or time of bus runs.”

At all three meetings, board members, along with Alban and FCPS Chief Operating Officer Paul Lebo, sat and listened, sometimes taking notes.

The hearings were not meant to be a back-and-forth exchange, but rather an opportunity for board members to hear from the public before making their final decision in October.

“This is a very uncomfortable, unfun process ... but it’s very important and we appreciate you all coming out to express your views,” board President Brad Young said as the first meeting began.

Large segments of communities came to the meetings together in order to show support for one another and make sure their concerns were heard, such as those who live in planning block 54, which sits south of U.S. 40 and is made up of the Tall Oaks, Lee Hill and Merricks neighborhoods in Monrovia. Children in this planning block attend Green Valley Elementary and Windsor Knolls Middle.

Under two redistricting options, which were presented to the public in June, planning block 54 was not affected. Under the superintendent’s plan, and according to a published map, the planning block is now split in two, with one portion going to a new elementary and middle school.

“We are now in the eleventh hour of this redistricting process, and it is only now that our neighborhood has been slated to switch,” said Jennifer Leonard, who lives in the portion of planning block 54 that is being moved. “It’s unfair that our neighborhood hasn’t been afforded the same courtesy of having time to process the new proposal as the neighborhoods affected in previous phases.”

Renee Mills, whose child would be moved from Windsor Knolls Middle to New Market Middle under the superintendent’s plan, agreed.

“I followed all the maps for months and months. We were never affected,” she said. “I'm not worried about the education they will receive; all the schools in our community are fantastic. What I am concerned about is that not enough time was actually given to the edits made to this final proposed plan.”

Patrick Morgan, an FCPS teacher, said he is worried about the social effect of redistricting on students, especially those in high school.

“I've seen children move at the high school level. I’ve seen how incredibly difficult that can be,” Morgan said. “The social connections, in particular, can really be a challenge. ... They now have to be in a new environment, make new friends, make new teammates.”

But despite the overwhelming number of families opposed to the superintendent’s plan, a few did show up in support of it.

“Although my individual children will be affected by the redistricting change ... I am trying to think in broader terms of the option that will best serve the entire community,” said Angela Moxley, a mother from Mount Airy. “Learning to deal with struggles is a reality of life and a good skill to learn from a young age.”

Moxley has a child in elementary school who would be moved to New Market Middle School.

“Learning to meet new people, make new relationships and adapt to new environments is something that will benefit them throughout their lives. ... No option is going to be ideal for anyone, and I'm OK with that,” she said.

In addition to specific community concerns, many speakers asked that current and incoming fifth- and eighth-graders be allowed to stay in their current feeder patterns to be "grandfathered" into the redistricting plan, similar to high school juniors and seniors.

As the Linganore meeting came to a close, Alban reminded everyone that a final decision has still not been made.

“For those of you who said you’ve been engaged from the beginning, stay engaged. ... You will still have time to give [the board] feedback before they vote,” Alban said. “I know that the board will pay careful attention to the feedback that you have all given.”

A final board vote on the redistricting plan is planned for October.

Follow Katryna Perera on Twitter: @katrynajill.

(7) comments


Coincidence that the Lansdale Development has been targeted for redistricting? The Landsdale Community did not spring up overnight. There was plenty of time to plan for school attendance prior to the first house being sold. The plan when houses were purchased was the development would be split between high schools, those who wanted their children to go to Urbana paid considerably more for their houses than those in the other school zone.

Unfortunately, the purchasers were not aware of the hostility and push back from the local community against the development. RALE, Residents Against Landsdale Expansion was a formal group against the community than was chaired by a current Frederick County Councilman. Discrimination against the development has been well documented, at a recent meeting the residents were described as “transients”.

The commute to Urbana HS is 4 miles, to Oakdale HS 7 miles, to Linganore HS 7.5 miles, nearly double the distance. In addition, there is only one way to access Fingerboard from Ed McClain Rd., and that Intersection at Ed McClain and 80 doesn’t have a traffic light, left turns are difficult and are prone to accidents.

The most direct way to Rt. 75 is frequently closed due to trucks hitting the railroad bridge, and traffic is normally congested as it it is a feeder road to 70. In addition to the route being twice as long, it is considerably a far more dangerous commute endangering student safety and would result in students frequently being late for class.

The paramount consideration for assigning schools is distance from the school. This has been upheld repeatedly in court. The proposed “gerrymandered” styled boundaries are capricious and have not been applied in an equitable manner, the excuses for the boundaries are not based on sound principles and have not considered the safety and welfare of the students.

The school board has not presented any research on traffic or safety patterns in regards to commutes, it appears the safety and well being of the students is not of paramount importance.

Distance and safety should be the first consideration for school assignments.


" frequently closed due to trucks hitting the railroad bridge,..." Interesting comment. I have not read about this happening recently. Does anyone know when a truck last hit the railroad bridge?


Less than a month ago, at least every couple of months. Check out the Frederick Scanner photos


I can understand the frustration on the part of many of the parents who are questioning the redistricting plan. I don't have children in the schools, but can't understand how it can be feasible and cost effective to bus a community of children more than double the distance from their neighborhood school. In some cases, a student who was able to easily walk to school may have to be transported by bus or private vehicle according to the new plan. Schools in some districts, like Urbana, have been over capacity for years. I really haven't heard many complaints from my neighbors about the overcrowded conditions. The only commentary has frequently been how happy they are that their children are attending really well managed and academically oriented and challenging schools.


I understand wanting your kids to attend the closest possible school but if you're in an overcrowding situation somebody obviously needs to be moved to a less crowded school. The neighborhoods around some of those Urbana schools are so densely packed that nobody should be surprised if they don't get the closest option.


These shows that Alban and the Board are putting on aren’t about public participation. They’re about the appearance of participation. That’s where FCPS shines. These decisions were made and finalized a year ago. The rest is about Alban’s image.


Yea who cares really. School districts have to make these moves all the time. Every parent thinks their child is more important then the other. Deal with it.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Engage ideas. This forum is for the exchange of ideas, insights and experiences, not personal attacks. Ad hominem criticisms are not allowed. Focus on ideas instead.
Don't threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
No trolls. Off-topic comments and comments that bait others are not allowed.
No spamming. This is not the place to sell miracle cures.
Say it once. No repeat or repetitive posts, please.
Help us. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.