Fact-checking the county executive race

The Frederick County stormwater fee has landed like a speck on local property tax bills in the past couple of years.

But clean water advocates and tax-averse political candidates alike say local residents should turn attention to the penny-sized fee as they prepare to enter the voting booth in November.

Known by its critics as the "rain tax," the fee is mandated by the state but is designed and sized by local officials. While some Maryland jurisdictions have created substantial levies, in some cases more than $100 per home, Frederick County leaders have opted to charge just 1 cent per property, enough to generate a meager $490 from July 2013 through mid-June. State officials have already warned that the 1-cent fee will fall far short of paying for necessary projects to control storm water runoff and prevent erosion and flooding.

Some candidates for local office say future county leaders should reexamine the fee for a possible increases while working with the state to moderate unfunded mandates. Others argue the state is asking local residents to suffer for pollution created elsewhere and vowed to take Maryland officials to court rather than increase the fee.

"The rain tax is completely absurd," said Blaine Young, a Republican candidate for county executive. "I don't think the residents of Frederick County should be having to foot the bill for what others have done, especially when it's based on faulty studies and science. With me, it's non-negotiable."

Republican council candidates Billy Shreve, Kirby Delauter and Tony Chmelik also said they would launch a legal challenge if the state tries to force the county to hike its stormwater fee.

Young said it's critical for voters to know where candidates stand on the fee and on strategies for dealing with state water quality mandates.

Amanda John, policy manager with the Potomac Conservancy, a nonprofit that focuses on water quality, agreed that the issue is important for Frederick County voters, though she doesn't share Young's perspective on it.

A study released last year showed that the majority of the county's watershed areas are suffering from poor biological health and bank erosion, and the Monocacy River experiences frequent flooding, she said. These problems will only intensify if the county fails to step up to the plate, she added.

"Storm water runoff is a local problem with local consequences," John said.

The sitting board of county commissioners, including Young, Shreve and Delauter, enacted the current penny-sized fee last year. Under the county's new form of government, which will take effect in December, a seven-member council will exercise control over the fee structure. The county executive could veto an increase and decide how to spend the money that is collected, according to county attorney John Mathias.

The stormwater fee requirement fits into broader efforts to clean up the Chesapeake Bay watershed. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency in 2010 established a strict "pollution diet" for six states that drain into the Bay, and in seeking to comply, Maryland has passed cleanup goals along to its counties.

Jan Gardner, the Democratic contender for county executive, says rather than battling the state, it is in the county's interests to preserve open lines of communication. She also argues the conversation shouldn't be about the fee itself but should center on the costs attached to cleanup targets.

County staff have estimated that the local cost to meet state watershed goals could total $1.88 billion by 2025. The county's five-year storm water permit, which is now being renewed through the state, could come with a price tag of $142.3 million, said Shannon Moore, who manages the county's office of sustainability and environmental resources. The permit is in its final phase of public review before the state issues the final version, Moore said.

Whether the county finds this money through the stormwater fee or in its general fund, taxpayers are ultimately footing the bill, Gardner said. She noted that the current cost estimate for the permit breaks down to more than $28 million annually, more than the county budgets for its public works division.

Gardner said she's not ready to suggest where the county might find money to deal with the additional cost burden. First, elected leaders should collaborate with state officials to make the permit less expensive, she said.

"We're still in an uncertain economy, and it's not a time to be hitting the taxpayers up. We need to try to advocate for ways to meet these goals that are more affordable," Gardner said.

For one thing, county leaders should reverse a decision by sitting commissioners allowing homes to be built closer to streams, she argued. Weakening the stream buffer requirement is a step in the wrong direction when the county is trying to control stormwater, she said.

Allowing the county to earn credit by supporting farm practices that reduce runoff could also help, Gardner said. A report by the Chesapeake Bay Commission found that such an agricultural trading program could reduce compliance costs by up to 90 percent, Moore said.

Gardner, Young and a number of council candidates also question the accuracy of the scientific assumptions that underpin cleanup targets. Linda Norris, a Democratic candidate for a council at-large seat, says she's open to adjusting the fee so long as the county isn't required to pay more than its share.

"I don't mind asking citizens to pay for a community need, but I want to make sure I'm asking for the right amount," she said.

Shreve and others say Maryland should stop pushing cleanup programs until other states shoulder some of the burden. A large amount of the pollution entering the Chesapeake Bay flows down from Pennsylvania, and Maryland's efforts will be futile unless its neighbors do their part, Shreve said.

Frederick County is currently involved in a partnership with nine other Maryland counties that are concerned about the state's approach to stormwater cleanup. The members of the Clean Chesapeake Coalition are pooling money to pay for legal advice and could collaborate on a court challenge against the state, Young said.

To help with its ongoing stormwater permit renewal process, the county has also hired lawyers from AquaLaw, a firm known for winning a case filed by the state of Virginia in response to EPA water quality requirements, Young added.

Follow Bethany Rodgers on Twitter: @BethRodgersFNP.

(13) comments

DickD

Ellen Bartlett cannot be reached because she is living near Circleville, W. V., where she went with Roscoe after he lost his last election. The rules, for County Council state you must be a resident of Frederick County for 12 months prior to running for the Council. She is violating the rules and the Election Board knows it; I told them, but they have failed to do anything about it.

No, she can't get mobile phone service there and when it snows at the 4,000' level during the winter, she will be unable to come to meetings too, if voters are dumb enough to elect her.

Dwasserba

What are the other five states doing?

sej58

Young stating that this is based on faulty science is a real concern. What qualifies him to know more then the experts in this field? I would love for him to state his references from the documents he has read that will justify his statement.

fourstoogesandthatotherguy_the

He bought himself an MBA and is now a changed person.

Extra Ignored

So does an Emerging Leaders MBA give you the competency to judge when a stormwater management plan is "based on faulty studies and science." Does Blaine Young even read the reports county employees write.

Extra Ignored

Montgomery County doesn't want to pay for Frederick County's pollution either.

https://frederickcountymd.gov/documents/7/229/MonocacyRiverFinalReport2009.PDF

Extra Ignored

To help with its ongoing stormwater permit renewal process, the county has also hired lawyers from AquaLaw, a firm known for winning a case filed by the state of Virginia in response to EPA water quality requirements, Young added.


Because of Blaine Young's its nonnegotiable position, is the county going to pay legal fees in excess of what the stormwater permit fee will cost plus pay the stormwater permit fee when it losses in court. Could we get a cost estimate on how much Blaine Young is willing to spend on principle at the taxpayer's expense.

Extra Ignored

Blaine Young, ... With me, it's non-negotiable."


Negotiating skills must not be part of the Emerging Leaders MBA.

Boyce Rensberger

Blaine Young says Frederick countians should not pay for what others have done to the bay. There is some reasonableness to that. But he doesn't say why Frederick countians should not foot the bill for what Frederick countians have done to the bay.

The Monocacy and the Potomac, both of which Frederick countians use to take away waste water, are significant contributors to the decline of the bay.

Then there is Billy Shreve who, according to this story, says Maryland should be a follower and not a leader in cleaning the bay. Maryland, which contains most of the bay, should not do anything, Billy says, until states farther away act first. So he is running not to be a leader but a follower.

Sallyforth

While Blaine Young, Billy Shreve and Kirby Delauter shuffle their feet and fight with the state, the adult in the room Jan Gardner charts out a reasonable course of action that will meet the county's obligations without putting undue stress on taxpayers.

cctjr64

Ellen Bartlett is still trying to find her glasses so she can read the charter, and yes from where she lives in West Virgina, not from her slum property down in Slabtown. Also disappointed that Bethany did not ask Stephen Dempsay, since he is also running as a write in.

FrederickFan

Jan Gardner once again demonstrates that she is a problem solver and a leader. Blaine Young once again demonstrates that he just wants to yell, scream and spend our money suing people. He has no understanding of the issue itself.

peachow

Ellen Bartlett couldn't be reached for comment? Hmmm, must be because they don't get cell service at their compound in West Virginia.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Engage ideas. This forum is for the exchange of ideas, insights and experiences, not personal attacks. Ad hominen criticisms are not allowed. Focus on ideas instead.
TURN OFF CAPS LOCK.
Don't threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
No trolls. Off-topic comments and comments that bait others are not allowed.
No spamming. This is not the place to sell miracle cures.
Say it once. No repeat or repetitive posts, please.
Help us. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.