After being outvoted during this month’s special session in Annapolis, Maryland Republicans have taken their case against the state’s new congressional districts map to the courts.
A lawsuit filed Tuesday in Anne Arundel County Circuit Court claims the map is gerrymandered and asks the court to find the plan approved by the General Assembly illegal. It further aims to prevent state officials from calling, holding, or certifying any elections under the plan.
The state map is a “clear example of the politicians picking their voters and not the voters picking their politicians,” said Del. Neil Parrott (R-Washington), one of the 12 plaintiffs in the case. Parrott is seeking the Republican congressional nomination in Maryland’s Sixth District.
The lawsuit names Linda Lamone, state administrator of the Maryland State Board of Elections, and William Voelp, chairman of the state Board of Elections, as defendants.
“We all know how gerrymandering works,” said Robert Popper, an attorney with Judicial Watch – a conservative group that aims to promote transparency, accountability and integrity in government – which filed the lawsuit on behalf of the 12 defendants.
Gerrymandering transfers power from voters to politicians, and it’s wrong no matter which party does it, he said.
The Maryland Democratic Party and the office of Maryland Senate President Bill Ferguson (D-Baltimore City) did not respond to requests for comment Wednesday.
Maryland Gov. Larry Hogan (R) created a Maryland Redistricting Reform Commission in 2015, with seven members appointed by Hogan and the majority and minority leaders in the General Assembly.
That commission recommended the formation of another commission, the Maryland Citizens Redistricting Commission, which Hogan created in January with three Democrats, three Republicans, and three political independents to redraw the state’s map of congressional districts.
That commission held more than 30 public meetings around the state, and in November it submitted a map that the Republican lawsuit said met the requirements of the U.S. and Maryland constitutions, as well as the federal Voting Rights Act.
“It also respected natural boundaries and the geographical integrity and continuity of municipal, county, and other political subdivisions, and its districts were geographically compact,” the lawsuit said.
Earlier this month, the General Assembly voted to adopt a plan the plaintiffs say is illegally gerrymandered and prevents them from being fairly represented in their districts.
The plan’s boundaries cause district lines to become “distorted and noncompact,” and to “deviate from and to cross existing political boundaries,” the lawsuit said.
Hogan vetoed the plan, but the veto was overridden the same day along party lines, with one Democrat crossing over to vote with Republicans.
The lawsuit splits Anne Arundel County into three congressional districts and connects the Eastern Shore to a section of Anne Arundel via the Chesapeake Bay Bridge, the complaint said.
It also divides the city of Baltimore amongst three districts, does the same with Baltimore County, and divides Montgomery County amongst four districts.
Frederick County includes portions of the Sixth and Eighth congressional districts, represented by U.S. Reps. David Trone (D) and Jamie Raskin (D), respectively.
“The Eighth District connects the suburbs of Washington, D.C. to the more Republican rural areas of Frederick and Carroll counties at the Pennsylvania border,” the lawsuit said.
It went on to stated the “Sixth Congressional District connects ... the poorest areas of the state in Garrett County, the westernmost rural county which borders Pennsylvania and West Virginia, with one of the wealthiest, Potomac, Maryland, which is a suburb of Washington, D.C. These two populations do not form a ‘community of interest.’”
“Because its districts cross so many political boundaries, the Plan ensures that representatives from these districts will face conflicting allegiances as to legislative initiatives that benefit one constituency at the expense of another,” the complaint said. “Because of these conflicts, representatives from these districts will represent their constituents, including plaintiffs, less effectively.”
Follow Ryan Marshall on Twitter: @RMarshallFNP
(36) comments
Maybe Maryland Republicans can help with deescalating this never ending cycle. Lets up pair with a Republican controlled state like Ohio and agree to have independent redistricting processes.
Maybe Maryland Republicans can take the lead to solve these national problem.
More stop the steel crap.
To summarize Parrot's case: "I am angry because the things my party does in other states for its own benefit are being used against me here."
Yup.
Why is it the most gerrymandered states are Republican and they don't complain. They only complain in the State they cannot do the same as Republicans are doing in other states. If the courts in Maryland rule for the Republicans it should be appealed, but this has been ruled on before.
Republicans in Maryland are beating a "dead horse"!https://www.morningsidecenter.org/teachable-moment/lessons/supreme-courts-momentous-ruling-gerrymandering
"On June 27, 2019 the U.S. Supreme Court, in Rucho v. Common Cause, announced a momentous decision: Federal courts have no power to police partisan gerrymandering. The high court overturned district court decisions in North Carolina and Maryland which held that state legislatures had engaged in extreme gerrymandering that had deprived citizens of their Constitutional rights."
Trone and Raskin can't find Western Maryland on any map.
They wanted to be part of WV, so who cares if they don’t?
Welcome to the Peoples Republik of Mareland.
Much better than the National Socialist Texas Reich.
Do you have their address? I want to tell them their name contradicts it’s self…..I tried to Google them but??? I could not locate an address for them…National Socialist Texas Reich? Or do they just exist in your imagination?
We’re always gerrymandered. Stop. Stop. Stop. There. Done.
When Democrats are in the minority and the Republican gerrymander the district maps, the Democrats cry foul. When Republicans are in the minority and the Democrats gerrymander the district maps, the Republicans cry foul. Efforts to create fair, unbiased, district maps have been implemented in some states, and they seem to be working, so long as the party in power feels the new district maps favor them. That's what happened in MD. A bipartisan commission created what appears to be a very fair map, but alas, the Democrats in power have decided to use their legislative poser to create a biased map that fits every definition of "gerrymandered" that you can come up with. Will a lawsuit prevail? Who knows? What relief can a court give? Toss the Democrats plan and adopt the Bipartisan Commission's plan? Send the legislature back to the drawing board? Create a court ordered districts plan? Candidates need to file by February 2022, so the districts map needs to be finalized by then, or the deadline for filing needs to be extended. How will primaries in the spring of 2022 take place if we're still waiting on the districts map to be finalized? Because of these deadlines, and not wanting to interfere with, or change the deadlines, I suspect the court will either toss the lawsuit, or rule that there is nothing illegal with the Legislature's Districts Map.
They have already ruled, it will not be accepted by the SCOTUS.
B
Your self-awareness about Gerrymandering does not track with your self-awareness about other subjects…I find that fascinating 🧐
Let's not forget that independents and those of other parties cry foul too. Gerrymandering causes actual harm (regardless who does it) because the efforts are based on those who actually vote, not those who theoretically are eligible to vote. Those who don't condemn gerrymandering regardless of which party does it are part of the problem and in my opinion, have warped morals.
Can someone give links to the old and new maps?
Here's a link to the Bipartisan Maps: https://redistricting.maryland.gov/Pages/final.aspx
Here's the legislature's maps: https://mgaleg.maryland.gov/Other/Redistricting/Final/webpage-final.pdf
Gerrymandering transfers power from voters to politicians, and it’s wrong no matter which party does it, he said.
Hear, hear!!!
Why not use zip codes for districts - or is that too logical?
Or perhaps use counties? May require a law or Constitutional change, but it would be worth it. Representatives representing the population of counties would be an easy, stable representative method.
You can't just use counties because of the need to balance district sizes. The average size of a congressional district based on the Census 2000 apportionment population is 646,952, well below MoCo's population for example. Additionally, northern MoCo is nothing like Bethesda or Silver Spring. Additionally, what do you do with cities if you are using counties as the basis?
Redistricting is tied to census data.
But that could be changed to avoid the farce.
And gerrymander zip codes, right?
If this makes it to a federal court I can easily imagine Republicans in those other states filing amicus briefs on behalf of MD Dems. The GOP has a lot more to lose if the MD Republicans succeed.
Are you suggesting there might be some hypocrisy in the GOP?
Hmmm….self-interest, perhaps.
Except the SCOTUS ruled on this in 2017 and it is legal, per the SCOTUS, Gladys. I wish it wasn't, but it is.
I know, Dick. I pointed out to nelga a few days ago that party affiliation isn’t a protected class like race. SCOTUS said partisan-based gerrymandering is not illegal.
I am sure if Republicans were in the majority they would design the map in their favor as they have done in many states. It shouldn’t work that way, but if does.
I am rallying behind these Republican lawmakers in their lawsuit. Hopefully they have the fortitude to fight this case all the way to the Supreme Court. Let's end gerrymandering altogether in this nation, including the dozens of states that have altered their political maps in favor of Republicans.
It has already been there and the Republicans lost!
So, Congress should write a law to make it illegal to discriminate based on party affiliation (or lack of party affiliation) and then SCOTUS can change its ruling.
MARYLAND Republicans lost. Republicans in the dozens of states gerrymandered the other way won.
And that is your defense for shameful behavior of the democratic controlled legislature of this state? Screw the voters (including independents) in this state because republicans screw voters in other states? That's a race to the bottom.
[thumbup]
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Keep it clean. No vulgar, racist, sexist or sexually-oriented language.
Engage ideas. This forum is for the exchange of ideas, not personal attacks or ad hominem criticisms.
TURN OFF CAPS LOCK.
Be civil. Don't threaten. Don't lie. Don't bait. Don't degrade others.
No trolling. Stay on topic.
No spamming. This is not the place to sell miracle cures.
No deceptive names. Apparently misleading usernames are not allowed.
Say it once. No repetitive posts, please.
Help us. Use the 'Report' link for abusive posts.