Though it has been enticingly tempting to react here to the political scene in America, I’ve been able to suppress my disbelief, anger and frustration and stick to subjects that do not ignite my wish to skewer the offending persons with my weapon of words. But a recent article in the Washington Post by Maura Judkins entitled “Crabby about picking” struck a match to a cultural, culinary and regional sacrament such that I must share these thoughts with you. Ms. Judkins attacked Maryland’s peculiar institution of picking and eating Chesapeake Bay blue crabs (Callinectes sapidus), our “beautiful savory.”

First, the article featured an innocent graphic of a crab, but the crab illustrated was not even a blue crab; I don’t know what kind it was supposed to be, but it was not the subject crab. Our sainted crab has spines on each side of its shell, conveniently provided by Mother Nature so that watermen can assess the legality of their catch.

The initial attack tried to make the case that picking the sweet, white meat from a properly seasoned, steamed crab was” too much work” and that the labor yields far too little reward. Then the author invokes the 10 times greater yield of the lobster, that denizen of the murky, green aquaria in grocery seafood counters. I will allow the author that picking a crab does offset to some small degree the calories. I choose to regard that labor versus calorie as an ancillary reward.

Some of those enjoying blue crabs actually have their spouses pick their crabs for them. In so doing, the recipient of the picked meat will not get the full effect of the seasonings, already being assimilated into the picker’s very flesh. (More of this anon.) Perhaps the same individual will ask his spouse to open his beer bottle for him as well, although I strongly suspect he’s having wine with his crab — and probably a timid rosé, at that.

Yes, pain is part of picking crabs. Get over it. Do you recall the scene in “Jaws” when Quint and Hooper compare their scars from shark bites? The male bonding was palpable. The two men become blood brothers of the sea. But not Police Chief Brody. Yes, you will get puncture wounds and fine, paper-like cuts from enthusiastic Blue crab picking. Bleeding digits do sting as Ms. Judkins suggests. The seasonings are, indeed, salt in the wounds, but with continued picking, they become numb, but remain supple enough to harvest the crab’s internals for the buttery, heavenly, white meat. Some things are worth fighting for. Those fingertips are the proud Purple Hearts of crab picking.

Then there are the complaints about the smell. I wonder if the smell issue might be because these critics haven’t truly been immersed in the aroma sufficiently (it’s not a “smell”; it’s more an “aroma” or “ambience!”) Appropriate inhalation of the steaming crab’s perfume should almost take one’s breath, and certainly water one’s eyes. Like marijuana, it won’t work if it’s not inhaled. “Oh, it takes me two days to get rid of the smell from my fingers! What can I do to get this smell out of my apartment?” Do you recall the character Robert Duvall played in “Apocalypse Now”? “I love the smell of napalm in the morning. … It’s the smell of victory!” Well, I love the smell of crabs in the house; it’s the smell of several hours of fun with my friends.

Pusillanimous pickers, you need to pick more, not less. Maybe the setting wasn’t correct. Perhaps your crab meal didn’t include Maryland tomatoes, fresh Maryland corn on the cob. Perhaps not even Natty Boh. I’ll bet far too many of you supplemented the crabs with its distant pushover cousin, steamed shrimp. Or worse, lobster. You didn’t commit.

I have a suggestion assured to bring about a lasting world peace. Assemble a summit of world leaders, outdoors, around strong but plain wooden picnic table in August. Cover the table, not with s sumptuous linen tablecloth, but with cast-off newspapers; classified ads work best as they contain no political news. Pour pitchers of Natty Boh; have several rolls of paper towels; trays of Maryland steamed blue crabs, slices of locally grown tomatoes and corn on the cob; a little butter and salt. Place a few ringers around the table to teach the uninitiated. For maximum safety, you won’t even need to supply knives. I open and pick my crabs with crab claws. “I don’ need no stinkin’ knife!” No one may leave the table until three or four trays of crabs and several pitchers of Natty Boh are consumed. After mastering the picking; getting smelly, pained fingers, messy hands and faces; immense piles of discarded shells, and the sleepy comfort of beer, they will understand one another. They will begin to plan the next crab feast. They will be blood brothers.

Steve Lloyd writes from Clover Hill and may be reached at

(6) comments


good tip on using the crab claw. I use a butter knife. The heavy end to crack the claws & the other end to get under the tab to pull the shell off. I can't always get that tip with just fingers. And don't you just love the people that say " I only eat the claws". We know its because they are to lazy to pick. So I'm fine with tossing them the claws as that lets me get to more bodys and not have to take time with the claws


Great column Steve! My crab feasts in my younger days were Barnegat Bay crabs. Moving to Maryland was eased by the fact that "Hey, they have crabs here", and I never looked back. Many a crab feast has been had at the Shorn2013 household. With crab prices dropping, there will be a few this summer.


Steve, that was your very best of so many lovely BofC columns. i laughed out loud seven times and snorted and grinned many more. I also welcome your satisfactory concern with and solution to world peace, although mine would have been a similar Italian feast.... My kids were raised in MD, so they totally agree with you on crab feasts! I do enjoy them although full appreciation of the many fine and enjoyable accompanying delights of crab feasting that you detailed were admittedly a gradually acquired taste for this animal-lover. (I remember as a child being startled by the news that chicken breasts, legs and thighs were related to actual chickens, and having my dinner look up at me from my plate always seemed um scary.) )We liberals are often full of new suggestions for global improvement, but my favorite conservative columnists, you among them, remind me of the small moments and privileges so worth cherishing in our remarkable home. Thank you for making my day. I will forward it to my crab-feast-loving daughters, and look forward as always to your next contribution....

Boyce Rensberger

Actually, Callinectes sapidus means "beautiful swimmer savory."


A lot to do about nothing.



Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Engage ideas. This forum is for the exchange of ideas, insights and experiences, not personal attacks. Ad hominem criticisms are not allowed. Focus on ideas instead.
Don't threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
No trolls. Off-topic comments and comments that bait others are not allowed.
No spamming. This is not the place to sell miracle cures.
Say it once. No repeat or repetitive posts, please.
Help us. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.