Have you heard that Facebook’s new “News” feature is going to include Breitbart, right alongside (with an emphasis on “right”) news sources such as The New York Times, The Washington Post and The Wall Street Journal?

I don’t like the idea of Breitbart enjoying the same space as those most respectable news sources. But I’m not a perfectionist. Unlike many folks I know, I’m staying on Facebook despite the fact that Facebook’s CEO Mark Zuckerberg is making choices I wouldn’t make.

Zuckerberg is selling a product I enjoy. In the same way that ethical vegetarians can occasionally dine out with friends at restaurants serving hamburger despite their deeply held personal belief that meat-eating is reprehensible, I’m keeping my Facebook page while keeping my distaste for Zuckerberg’s decisions intact.

So I won’t pay attention to Breitbart on Facebook, just as I don’t pay attention to it now.

I suspect I like Facebook precisely because ever since I was a kid, I’ve thought of the world as full of potential pen pals.

But now I don’t have to wait for weeks to hear what they have to say.

Ray Oldenburg is a sociologist who developed the concept of a “Third Place,” a public arena where individuals gather to make friends, relax and be their authentic selves. The Third Place, in terms of significance in our lives, comes right after home and the workplace. Oldenburg argues that virtual spaces can’t be Third Places; He sees hair salons, coffee shops and, one presumes, the bar in “Cheers” as the physical setting for encounters that provide neutral ground, where social status doesn’t matter, where the central activity is conversation and where everybody knows your name.

For me, Facebook does that. It’s as close as I can get to throwing around a Frisbee, in the days before it became Ultimate. You’d throw it to a friend and wonder if they’d send it back to you or flick it in someone else’s direction or miss it all together. I do that now on my page, except I throw around ideas, lines from books, bits of poems, links to articles and the occasional photograph.

Some go astray, and others dive straight into the earth like a dart. But a few get caught and begin long, wild flights, passing through many hands. These are as much fun as endless games in the park, talks late into the night or any connection of disparate individuals willing to engage in an exchange of stories.

I asked the experts — my own friends on Facebook — why they’re on the page. “It’s my lifeline to friends and a built-in audience,” is Amy Hartl Sherman’s answer. I met Amy at the Erma Bombeck Writer’s Workshop several years ago, but we’ve become friends through trading unladylike responses to world events (she doesn’t like Breitbart either) and personal matters (both of us deal with feral creatures in our yards; she videotapes hers).

Nanci McBrearty Pelati says she uses Facebook “to see what the parts that make me whole are up to,” while Jane Smiley (Pulitzer-Prize winning author and, yes, my FB friend) says she uses it as follows: “Eavesdropping. Introvert connecting. Too tall for parties.”

I’ve been comforted, cheered and reassured by responses on Facebook at times when I needed them. Others rely on it as well, especially those like Mary Lou H. Solomon, who describes herself as “being very social but sometimes an introvert” and discovered that Facebook allows her to be both.

Those who are self-defined introverts or wary of social interaction or whose circumstances limit their access to in-person conversation can find an oddly personal solace in a virtual space.

The clarity and honesty of Christina Smith’s admission that her friends on Facebook “keep the loneliness at bay” is echoed by Jamie Spriggs’ comment that Facebook can act as a “caregiver’s lifeline to the outside world. It also provides a welcome distraction from whatever I don’t want to be doing.”

And although Nancy Hanlon O’Connell’s response that she goes to FB for “Distraction, Obsession, Compulsion” makes Zuckerberg’s creation sound like a series of Calvin Klein’s perfumes, I understand her point.

I’ve never looked to Facebook for my news; for that I rely on newspapers. I rely on journalists and members of the Fourth Estate for information, discovery and evidence. Like the rest of America, I depend on a free press.

So while I don’t depend on Facebook, I like the place, and even with interlopers like Breitbart milling about, I’ll choose the company I keep.

Gina Barreca is an English professor at the University of Connecticut and the author of “If You Lean In, Will Men Just Look Down Your Blouse?” and eight other books. She can be reached at www.ginabarreca.com.

Copyright 2019 Tribune Content Agency.

(5) comments


I participated in newsgroups and international listservs when they were "what's *that*?" oddities, back when people asked things like, "what's 'online' mean?" I had to learn programming languages to put up webpages as a volunteer, then navigate criticism of same from newbie users with challenged home computer systems...or systems too "bells and whistles" for their level of competence...FB was accessible from the start and I was at first, suspicious and cautious, then as it became more and more a party I was "commanded" to attend and "foolish" not to, I decided to see how long someone can resist in the face of cultural pressure. I found that eventually there is no pressure. The FB world rolls along. That's not me checking my phone any free moment anywhere, even during a pause in conversation. I just don't need to know everything there is to know all the time.


Well said, Gina. We can take what we like when there are choices.


What a bunch of dumb women. Everything they say is pure garbage. "my lifeline to friends and a built-in audience.“ Ha! On what basis does that woman conclude anyone is her audience or even reads or cares about what she posts? Has she spoken to any of them to find out or does she just speculate about it? "to see what the parts that make me whole are up to." Ha! On what basis does that woman conclude what she sees is true or accurate? Has she spoken to anybody to find out or does she just assume it's correct? "a welcome distraction from whatever I don’t want to be doing." Ha! In other words, I'm a lazy bum and would rather waste time on FB than do something useful. The best of all: "So while I don’t depend on Facebook..." Ha! Lady you're as addicted to and psychologically dependent on FB trivia and falsity as much any opiate gulper is to their stinking drug. So tell me again why people should believe or trust what they see on FB?


There are many choices in life. No need to disagree so with the choices of others.


Thanks, Prince, for another word salad doused with vitriol dressing.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Engage ideas. This forum is for the exchange of ideas, insights and experiences, not personal attacks. Ad hominem criticisms are not allowed. Focus on ideas instead.
Don't threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
No trolls. Off-topic comments and comments that bait others are not allowed.
No spamming. This is not the place to sell miracle cures.
Say it once. No repeat or repetitive posts, please.
Help us. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.