At the end of a long, long journey, Frederick County seems to have arrived at a good place from which to protect our treasured Monocacy River.

After considerable pushing and pulling, the Monocacy Scenic River Citizens Advisory Board was dissolved last year when the Carroll County commissioners decided to pull out of the compact.

The advisory board was created five decades ago with Carroll, which shares the river as a border with Frederick at the north end of the county.

By the time of the divorce last year, it was clear to everyone that the two counties had irreconcilable differences and a split would be best for both sides.

Once, the two counties had shared similar outlooks on the environment and the growth policies, but increasingly they had diverged. When the advisory board began working three years ago to update the guidelines for protecting the river, deep philosophical differences emerged.

The conflict basically boiled down to a choice between believing that the interests of the property owners near the streams were paramount or recognizing that the quality of the water in the river was most important. Carroll representatives thought the first true; Frederick representatives the second.

Last week, the Frederick County Council voted to create a new version of the river advisory board composed exclusively of Frederick County residents, the Sustainable Monocacy Commission.

The new commission will be charged with overseeing the health of the Monocacy River and its tributaries, and with recommending policies to protect them. It must follow the guidelines of the Monocacy River Plan, which was approved by the council last April.

Council President M.C. Keegan-Ayer introduced the legislation on behalf of County Executive Jan Gardner. We are pleased with the proposed makeup of the commission, and believe it will give a voice to property owners, farmers, environmentalists and the general public.

The nine voting members of the board will include:

  • Two property owners who live along the Monocacy River.
  • Three residents who don’t live along the river.
  • Three members of the local scientific community (biology, ecology, life science, natural resources or related fields).
  • One member of the local agricultural community.
  • One member of the general public.

All must be registered voters and residents of Frederick County. The commission will also include two non-voting members, one representing the city of Frederick and one representing the County Council.

In an effort to continue trying to coordinate efforts with Carroll County, the commission will meet at least once a year with whatever board Carroll officials create.

Judging by the final years of the advisory board, we do not hold out much hope that the commission will often find itself in agreement with the Carroll representatives, but it will be useful to maintain a dialogue and lines of communication with our neighbor to the east.

We believe that the county has ended up in a place where our river will have the best chance of being properly protected. At the same time, property owners will not be unduly interfered with. Environmental protection is always a balancing act, and this commission gives us the best hope of a good balance.

(1) comment


I hope the board is going to take quick action on 2 critical and time sensitive issues. 1) the sewage treatment plant across the river from the Fords Crossing trail at the Monocacy battlefield. This short and accessible trail is beautiful and bio-diverse. It is also overwhelmed by raw sewage smell 70% of the time. Not a whiff, a wall of stench. When I noticed a pipe was running from the plant into the river, I called the park service to see if the water had been tested. The park service told me that the water HAS NOT BEEN TESTED downstream from the pipe. This is mind blowing to me. People swim, tube and paddle on the river and we don't know if there are illegal amounts of fecal matter in the river. Water quality testing needs to be done ASAP.

2) The amount of soil run off in the Monocacy needs to be addressed. This is a result of non-sustainable farming practices. You don't need to be a scientist to see the water looking like chocolate milk all the way down to where it runs into the Potomac. All of us should not have to pay the price for farmer's that do not want to run their businesses properly. Grants should be provided to plant more tree buffers and more incentives/or penalties should be enforced. If you drive past a farm and the pasture is over grazed, muddy and the cows are overrunning the one muddy stream in the pasture, its evident what the problem is.

Take action and stop debating endlessly. We are losing something that we can never get back again.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Engage ideas. This forum is for the exchange of ideas, insights and experiences, not personal attacks. Ad hominem criticisms are not allowed. Focus on ideas instead.
Don't threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
No trolls. Off-topic comments and comments that bait others are not allowed.
No spamming. This is not the place to sell miracle cures.
Say it once. No repeat or repetitive posts, please.
Help us. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.