Standing on North Market Street recently on a busy night in downtown Frederick, Mardelle Poffenberger said she watched the foot traffic and noticed how many people turned around just north of Third Street.

One of the problems, Poffenberger said, is a vacant property that stretches nearly half of the 300 block of North Market Street. The property, once home to a market called Carmack-Jay’s and still colloquially referred to by that name, has been vacant for 17 years.

“People would walk a few stores down (on Third Street), and see the vacancies and nothing going on, and turn around, again and again,” she said.

City officials, as well as people living and working near the property, including Poffenberger, co-owner of Bravura Arts and Framing in the 400 block of North Market Street, say they hope that changes soon.

The city of Frederick is hosting a community meeting at 7 p.m. May 13 at the city’s annex building at 140 W. Patrick St. to discuss the history and best use of the property. Mayor Randy McClement scheduled the meeting to give people an opportunity to come out and tell the property owner, Douglas Development, their thoughts on the best use of the property, he said.

While residents have been hoping a grocer or market will move in, McClement said he wants to see if the residents would be open to other ideas.

Mike Dickson, CEO of Seed of Life Nurseries, and Dewey Stewart, who runs the Frederick City Market, have thought about trying to get an indoor farmers market on the site, which could be run by a co-op, Dickson said.

Downtown residents now have to go out of downtown for groceries, and this would bring the food to them, he said.

Developers and downtown leaders have been talking about ideas for the property that will have people excited, said Alderwoman Donna Kuzemchak. She said she could not elaborate more at this time.

Kuzemchak, a Realtor for Mackintosh Realtors, said people will start to see more development happening, with the uptick in the real estate market.

Mackintosh was recently brought on as the new leasing agent for the site. Since, there seems to be more movement on getting the site fixed up and rented out, said Richard Griffin, the city’s economic development director.

“This shift is a real positive step,” Griffin said. “We feel that the owner and leasing agent will come up with something to use the property appropriately. What that is, we don’t know yet.”

A new tenant has moved in to part of a building on the property that faces the street, but the main building on the site is still empty, McClement said.

Residents call for action

One week before McClement set up the community meeting, the people who run the Facebook page “The City of Frederick’s Blight Problem” encouraged the page’s more than 1,100 followers to email public officials to ask them to do something about the vacant property.

“We decided that enough is enough with this property,” Andy Stout, a downtown resident and one of the people who run the page, wrote in an email. “No news from city hall (or anyone else) about it for what seems like years. Since (McClement) and the gang only respond to public shaming, and since the mayor loves to be led by the nose to problem solving, we figured we would help him find his way.”

In a separate email to an alderman, Stout said he suggested a community meeting.

Two days later, McClement announced the meeting, Stout said.

Now, Stout said he wants the mayor to give the residents credit for starting the conversation.

McClement acknowledged that he received a few emails from residents just before setting up the meeting, but he said he had the meeting in the works long before hearing from them.

“It’s Murphy’s law,” he said.

‘New chapter’

The main building on the site was built in 1959, when Carmack’s Inc. built it for a market. The site was acquired by Jay’s Market in 1959 and the market then became Carmack-Jay’s, which operated until 1995.

The city bought the property after Carmack-Jay’s closed, and sold it to a company that opened a new market on the site, but then the market closed less than two years later and the city took the property back.

After thinking about trying to operate a city-run market on the site, the city sold the building in July 2002 to Douglas Development, which then spent $900,000 renovating the outside of the building and tried, but failed, to find potential tenants.

No one really expected the property to be vacant for as long as it has been, Griffin said.

The site is an enormous opportunity loss for the neighborhood, he said.

Before moving to the 400 block of North Market Street, Bravura used to be near Market and Patrick streets, with all of the foot traffic that comes with that location, Poffenberger said.

“Then, I moved up here to no man’s land,” she said.

A new tenant at the old Carmack-Jay’s property would really help, she said.

Hopefully this is a new chapter for the property, McClement said.

“Of course we want it full,” he said. “It helps the vibrancy of our city to keep things full.”

Follow Jen Fifield on Twitter: @JenAFifield.

(13) comments


Doesn't this article picture the same merry-go-round the City has been riding on for more than a decade? Even the mayor can't come up with anything more than "poilitical speak" and wishful thinking. We're still stuck with IF and MAYBE, from any level of governance represented here?

Why is the Mayor holding more public meetings except to challenge the public to a duel of words on issues neither he, his staff, or the balalnce of Frederick's part-time elected leaders are capable of answering. They already know the answers to the questions that the Public may bring, IF they even show up, but this "meeting agenda", as in the recent and distant past, is nothing more than another staged event and repeat performamnce, depicting the same lies that governance has used over the last 17 years, if you were counting, to ignore their public constituency and only PRETEND to be involved in making Frederick or Frederick County into a going concern for the future, other than making more EXCUSES, over and over again, that there is light at the end of the tunnel that's already 17 years long and still no light found so far.

Simply said, I'm not taking the bait government is using with this scripting message, that is intended only to distract us more from the issue than having a real say in what WE should do with our blight and vacant business establishments, at any time within the latest fiscal year.

Frederick is for sale with an investment agenga to build as many housing roofs as local governmant can be persuaded to authorize. It's refered to as yet another "bedroom community", not unlike what you will find in the likes of Stafford, Spotsylvania Counties and Fredericksburg Virginia that are also just 50+ miles from Washington, D.C.

AND , all you have to do is look at the last four years of governance to see what I'm leading up to. This article is only the tease for coming events.


jwang: Parking is not the issue with Trader Joe's stating that they are not coming to Frederick. "Asking" a company to come to the area is not going to make it so.


Continuing with the farmers market theme, why not see if The Common Market may be able to install a mini market on this site?


Trader Joe's already stated to those who inquired to them about coming to Brunswick and/or Jefferson that they were not coming to Frederick County. Trader Joe's and Whole Foods research hard as to whether a possible location is likely to work out. There has to consistently be enough people who are truly interested and able to purchase at those stores to make it worth their while to do everything involved in establishing a new location.

Even though I'm not in the city, I would hope that whatever goes in there will be something that will be a meaningful place in which to buy. The lower-end - and I mean lower-end - grocery stores in there in the past have been terrible. I know of a couple cases where that place was the pits for what little a family member bought there just because it was close (at that time, of course). Also, I remember when that Tesoro grocery store on Jefferson Pike was there. I remember just reading the weekly ad in the paper at the time. I could tell that their customer base was the poorest of the poor. -Way off brand canned goods, low quality all-around. Who needs or wants that? Sure enough, that place closed. After all, people with whatever food stamps are called these days (SNAP?) can shop at nicer stores than that.


How about demolish all the buildings and build a 3 story Parking Garage to generate money for the City? So that businesses have parking to expand upon. Then we can ask Trader Joes to open nearby and there will be ample Parking.


What business would want to come to Frederick?????


...or a trader Joe's , or Whole Foods


Continuing the theme of the Farmers Market idea, we'd be happy to bring our flower cart to the site as soon as this weekend.


Plenty of parking for a police and government offices, local of course.


Great examples of the failure of county policy and regulations not being updated. You have to actualy enjoy seeing this.


Oh, yea . . . Hargett Farm

What a wonderful investment portfolio . . .


". . . vacant for 17 years . . ."

Seriously --- an example of why government should *not* try to compete with commercial interests or make (poor) investments like this one.

What are the reasons for the vacancy . . . . hmmm?

If North Ponte solved the 'housing blight' issue, what are the reasons?

Income? Local population? Wegmans?


Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Engage ideas. This forum is for the exchange of ideas, insights and experiences, not personal attacks. Ad hominen criticisms are not allowed. Focus on ideas instead.
Don't threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
No trolls. Off-topic comments and comments that bait others are not allowed.
No spamming. This is not the place to sell miracle cures.
Say it once. No repeat or repetitive posts, please.
Help us. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.