CHS Softball

Courtney Eyler, left, verbally committed to play softball at Penn State before she ever played a game at Catoctin High. On Wednesday, she’ll sign a National Letter of Intent to play for the Nittany Lions, despite a torn ACL that will prevent her from taking the field if a spring sports season is held in 2021.

Courtney Eyler clapped, cheered, dished out high-fives — and anything else that fit into the category of good teammate.

Eyler was a portrait of positive body language during that July afternoon softball tournament in Kansas, masking the emotional pain that burned inside.

“Inside, it was killing her that this happened,” her grandmother, Brenda Eyler, said.

Earlier that day, Courtney deftly maneuvered her way around the opposing team’s catcher to score the winning run for the 18-and-under PA Strikers — a Pennsylvania-based travel softball team. But when she stepped on home plate, her right knee buckled.

Courtney’s worst fear — a torn ACL — wasn’t confirmed until a week later, but numerous questions had already started racing through her mind. After all, she was a Catoctin High School senior who had verbally committed to play softball at Penn State more than two years earlier. But the coaching staff that recruited her was no longer there, and that verbal commitment she gave to the Nittany Lions certainly didn’t qualify as a binding contract.

“Penn State got a new coaching staff — they very easily could have looked at a list and said, ‘We don’t want you,’ or change the offer,” Catoctin coach Jessica Valentine said.

If Courtney expressed any fears last summer, they won’t be on display today, when high school athletes can put their commitment to play sports in writing. Athletes such as Courtney have the option to renege on their verbal commitments and choose another school, but she didn’t go that route. Instead, she’ll be rewarded for her loyalty when she signs a National Letter of Intent to play softball for Penn State.

The gratitude the younger Eyler feels will become apparent to anyone who sees her pen a signature on her letter of intent. For someone who is recovering from an ACL injury, that gratitude extends well beyond the world of softball. And she’s gained an inner strength that she wouldn’t have ever had if she hadn’t suffered her injury.

“I obviously didn’t want this for me, but I’m almost glad that it happened because it made me appreciate a lot of things more,” Eyler said.

Armed with an abundance of natural talent, Eyler was viewed as a can’t-miss recruit before she entered high school. The ball jumped off her bat, and she could field and throw with a metronome-like rhythm at shortstop.

Those abilities translated into a .595 batting average with eight home runs, three triples, 11 doubles and 24 RBIs during her sophomore season. She currently ranks as the country’s 79th-best high school player, according to the website

But Eyler, who also played basketball at Catoctin, wasn’t thinking about hitting a softball or chasing down a grounder on the infield while recovering from her surgery.

“I wasn’t able to walk on my own,” she said. “I wasn’t able to do a lot for myself.”

So if she performs any sort of routine task, she doesn’t take it for granted. Eyler now expresses gratitude for doing something as simple as taking a shower. She couldn’t get the bandages on her knee wet after her surgery, forcing her to wash her hair over a sink.

Also, Eyler wasn’t able to drive for six weeks.

“I just started skipping, which seems like something so natural that a lot of people can do [easily],” she said. “For me, it’s big because I really haven’t been able to move a lot — do a lot of cardio.”

Eyler hopes she can start running at the end of the month or in early December, but she doesn’t foresee herself returning to competitive softball until the summer. And at that point, she could see herself relegated to designated hitter duties.

Aside from the physical aspect of the injury, Eyler said she has gained a new-found maturity.

“I’m really glad that I’ve watched myself grow, not only physically but mentally,” she said.

Her rehabilitation certainly required mental toughness as Eyler fought through some significant physical pain during physical therapy for her knee.

“Whenever you fail, you just get back up and keep trying,” Eyler said. “I wasn’t able to bend my leg. It was painful, but …. [my doctor told me] you need to feel some pain to get better. ‘Push through the pain’ is definitely something I’ve learned.”

Approaching her rebab with that kind of positive attitude wouldn’t surprise Valentine, who said Eyler’s work ethic matches her talent.

“A lot of kids that are gifted or born with certainly athletic abilities just rely on those abilities,” Valentine said. “That’s not Courtney. She works hard, and if you ask her, [whatever she has accomplished] is not good enough.”

Valentine also praised Eyler for looking at the big picture when making her college decision. Eyler plans on majoring in pre-med at Penn State, and the school’s options for a college education played a big role in her early commitment.

“She made the choice as a person, not necessarily as an athlete,” Valentine said. “Her choice was an all-around choice, not just softball at Penn State. A lot of kids don’t do that, and I’m really proud of her for doing that.”


Here is a list of Frederick County athletes who are signing National Letters of Intent on Wednesday's early signing day to play sports at Division I or Division II colleges. If names are missing, email omissions to


Courtney Eyler, Penn State, softball


Rose Bubakar, BYU, basketball


Jade Catlin, Virginia Tech, lacrosse

Bailey Broadbent, Jacksonville, lacrosse

Alyssa Daley, Naval Academy, lacrosse

Brynn Hoffman, Jacksonville, lacrosse

Zach Martin, Maryland, baseball

Saylor Poffenbarger, Connecticut, basketball


Gabby Averill, Mount St. Mary's, lacrosse

Kailey Balcombe, Flagler College, lacrosse

Sam Mogar, Limestone, field hockey

Hayley Taylor, Duquesne, swimming

Thomas Johnson

Mei Homman, Frostburg, soccer

Jacob Orr, Maryland, baseball

Trevor Yusko, Frostburg, baseball

St. John's Catholic Prep

Merryn Eaton, Notre Dame College (Ohio), lacrosse

Jasmine Huskey, Mount St. Mary's, basketball


Skylar Andrews, Frostburg, girls soccer

Lauren Moore, Trevecca Nazarene University, softball

Rachel Nichols, Frostburg, lacrosse

Jackson VanTassell, Radford, baseball


Brooke Alban, West Virginia, gymnastics

Ella Auderset, North Carolina, track and field

Jadelyn Coleman, High Point, lacrosse

Maggie Goodwin, Virginia Commonwealth University, field hockey

Heidi Hartje, West Virginia, gymnastics

Avery Hines, Stony Brook University, lacrosse

Jack Jozwiak, Delaware, lacrosse

Jason Jozwiak, Delaware, lacrosse

Eric Kolar, Maryland, lacrosse

Jason Kolar, Delaware, lacrosse

Emma Regan, Le Moyne College, lacrosse

Hailey Smith, Illinois, National Wheelchair Basketball Association

Natalie Voorhees, Pittsburgh, lacrosse

(1) comment


Well done to all of these Frederick County student athletes.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it clean. No vulgar, racist, sexist or sexually-oriented language.
Engage ideas. This forum is for the exchange of ideas, not personal attacks or ad hominem criticisms.
Be civil. Don't threaten. Don't lie. Don't bait. Don't degrade others.
No trolling. Stay on topic.
No spamming. This is not the place to sell miracle cures.
No deceptive names. Apparently misleading usernames are not allowed.
Say it once. No repetitive posts, please.
Help us. Use the 'Report' link for abusive posts.

Thank you for reading!

Already a member?

Login Now
Click Here!

Currently a News-Post subscriber?

Activate your membership at no additional charge.
Click Here!

Need more information?

Learn about the benefits of membership.
Click Here!

Ready to join?

Choose the membership plan that fits your needs.
Click Here!